Backup running backs may not be the most thrilling players to draft in fantasy football leagues, but identifying the right handcuffs can significantly influence a team's chances of clinching a championship or falling short of the playoffs. In today's NFL, the lines between starting and backup running backs often blur due to platoon systems employed by many teams. Additionally, the landscape can shift rapidly as injuries or performance issues can lead to changes in depth charts, impacting fantasy outcomes. With these factors in mind, a ranked assessment of each NFL team's handcuff running back is provided, taking into consideration their standalone value and potential if elevated to a starting role. Evaluations are based on training camp feedback, snap counts, and past performance trends, drawing upon fantasy statistics from sources such as FantasyPros.com using PPR data.

In New Orleans, Kendre Miller once held promise as a desirable handcuff but has since struggled to meet expectations. Drafted in the third round in 2023, Miller has yet to establish himself as a productive player in the league, accumulating only 454 yards and two touchdowns on 95 touches over 14 games. Although the Saints continue to keep him on the roster in the hopes he will fulfill his potential, he is unlikely to find favor in all but the deepest fantasy leagues. Conversely, the Cincinnati Bengals may have snagged a hidden talent in sixth-round rookie Chase Brown. Although projections indicate that Brown is set to lead the backfield in 2025, his competition for backup duties, including recent signings and available veterans, could allow for an increased role should the opportunity arise.

In Green Bay, third-round pick Tyler Lloyd had an unremarkable rookie season, seeing action in only one game and recording a mere 18 yards from scrimmage on seven touches. Injuries have plagued Lloyd's progress, including hip and ankle issues, along with more recent complications. Given that reigning Pro Bowler Josh Jacobs continues to dominate the backfield, Lloyd's contributions are expected to remain limited. Alternatively, Saquon Barkley's inaugural year with the Philadelphia Eagles exceeded expectations and netted him a significant contract extension. While Barkley remains the focal point of the Eagles' top-ranked rushing attack, any hopes of backups like Will Shipley becoming notable contributors hinge on Barkley's health and performance continuity.