The NBA thrives on the brilliance of its star players, yet it is essential to acknowledge those who have made significant contributions without receiving the same level of recognition. Identifying the most underrated players in the league over the past five years involves a degree of subjectivity, as it aims to highlight consistent contributors who may not possess traditional star credentials.

To create a comprehensive list of candidates, certain criteria were established. Players eligible for a top-five ranking must be those recognized for their contributions during the specified timeframe. Royce O'Neal, who retains his fifth-place position from the previous year, epitomizes an elite role player. Despite potential criticisms regarding his consecutive placements on the list of most underrated players, O'Neal stands out for his efficiency as a low-usage wing who excels in three-point shooting and defensive efforts. Notably, his accomplishments since the 2020-21 season include 724 three-pointers at an impressive 38.8 percent conversion rate, making him the player with the lowest usage rate among those attaining similar shooting efficiency.

Isaiah Hartenstein has emerged as a notable talent, transitioning to the reigning champion Oklahoma City Thunder with a significant three-year, $87 million contract. However, few appreciate the contextual elements surrounding this move. The Thunder's team option on the final season of his contract suggests it functions effectively as a two-year deal. Hartenstein's versatility on both ends of the court has been remarkable, enabling him to excel in various roles, from screen-setting and rebounding to shot-blocking and facilitating play. His impact is statistically supported, with the ability to match rebounding and assist rates comparable to only Anthony Davis and Victor Wembanyama during this period.

Meanwhile, Josh Hart often receives criticism for his shooting inefficiencies, particularly from long range. Despite valid concerns, Hart’s relentless hustle and impactful play on both sides of the ball contribute to his team's success. Historically, his teams have performed better with him on the court, which underscores his value. In the previous season, Hart faced challenges in team dynamics, influencing his on/off statistics. However, his ability to enhance offensive pace, contribute in transition, and defend multiple positions showcases his importance. Furthermore, his true shooting percentage of 58.7 exceeds the league average, highlighting his overall offensive contribution despite scrutiny over his shooting range.

Derrick White’s presence on this list may invite debate, particularly due to his recognition over the past two seasons as a candidate for All-NBA honors. Nonetheless, the absence of an actual selection from either All-Star or All-NBA rosters suggests a continuing underappreciation of his skill set. Defense has long been his strong suit, but recent developments reveal a significant improvement in his offensive game, showcasing better decision-making and shooting. Despite the advantages provided by a talented Boston Celtics roster, White's ability to perform at a high level even in Jayson Tatum's absence speaks volumes about his growth as a player.

Ivica Zubac's trajectory has culminated in heightened recognition, including consideration for Most Improved Player and Defensive Player of the Year awards. His year-over-year development has been steady and often understated until this past season, when he emerged as a key contributor. Zubac's improvement extends beyond surface-level statistics, as he has consistently ranked among the best in rim points saved per 100 possessions. This impressive defensive performance distinguishes him among a small group of players maintaining impressive averages over time, further solidifying his candidacy as one of the league's underrated talents through his all-around game.