NFL Training Camp Holdouts and Contract Disputes: An In-Depth Analysis

As NFL training camps commence, contract disputes and player holdouts become significant topics of discussion within the league. This year's narrative is reminiscent of Cuba Gooding Jr.'s famous line from 'Jerry Maguire,' 'Show me the money!' The start of training camps brings with it various contract negotiations across the league, highlighted by situations like those involving the Cincinnati Bengals. During the opening days of camp, the Bengals saw notable absentees in rookie defensive end Shemar Stewart and All-Pro edge rusher Trey Hendrickson. While Stewart's contractual issue has been resolved, Hendrickson remains a key focus as his negotiations continue.
Trey Hendrickson's situation is noteworthy, as he has been seeking an upgraded contract despite significant contributions to the Bengals. Having made four Pro Bowls since joining the team, Hendrickson has accumulated 57 sacks, including impressive back-to-back seasons with 17.5 quarterback takedowns that led the NFL last season. Despite these achievements, he ranks just eleventh in average earnings per year at $21 million for his position, according to Over The Cap. As he enters the final year of his contract, Hendrickson seeks both increased financial security and a long-term commitment from Cincinnati.
Bengals owner Mike Brown expressed optimism regarding a resolution for Hendrickson's situation at the start of training camp, emphasizing that a deal would likely come to fruition. However, discussions have reportedly hit a snag concerning guaranteed money structures within the Bengals front office. Reports indicate that negotiations are ongoing, but the team's historical policy of limiting guarantees beyond the first year complicates the talks. There is growing speculation that if Hendrickson's desire for future guarantees goes unmet, he may refuse to participate in the season on his current deal. As the Bengals consider their options, they also have young talents like Joseph Ossai, who recently enjoyed a breakout season, and rookie first-round pick Myles Murphy to support their defensive line moving forward.
The scenario for Washington Commanders wide receiver Terry McLaurin mirrors the negotiations surrounding Hendrickson. Widely regarded as one of the NFL's most underrated receivers, McLaurin has consistently delivered strong performances despite subpar quarterback support over his career. With 1,000-plus yard seasons in each of the last five years and a record 13 touchdown receptions last year, McLaurin's contract value remains an issue. He currently earns $23.2 million annually, which ranks him 17th among wide receivers, just behind newly acquired teammate Deebo Samuel, who earns $23.85 million.
McLaurin publicly expressed frustration about the slow pace of contract talks before training camp began, emphasizing his desire to remain a part of the organization where he has built his career. In response, general manager Adam Peters affirmed the team’s commitment to getting a deal done. Reports indicate that McLaurin will now be placed on the PUP list, shifting his status from a holdout to a hold-in, allowing him to avoid fines while still seeking a revised contract. The Commanders' receiving corps, already hindered by recent injuries, may grapple with depth issues as negotiations continue.
Turning to the Buffalo Bills, running back James Cook has also engaged in contract discussions after demonstrating his worth over the last two seasons. Following a stellar 2023 campaign with 1,122 rushing yards, Cook is advocating for an increase from his current contract, which averages approximately $1.5 million per year. His performance places him in a compelling position, especially when compared to his peers in the league. Reports suggest Cook is seeking a new deal potentially worth around $15 million annually, solidifying his ranking among the league's elite running backs.
Although Cook has reported to training camp and actively participates in practices to mitigate financial penalties, his assertion that he deserves a higher salary remains clear. Bills general manager Brandon Beane acknowledged the complexities of the negotiations, hinting that reaching an agreement might take time. With few alternatives available at the running back position, Cook's leverage increases as the Bills evaluate their options in a critical upcoming season.
Green Bay Packers offensive lineman Elgton Jenkins presents yet another intriguing contractual scenario amidst training camp. Jenkins, celebrated for his versatility after being drafted in 2019, is adept at playing multiple lineman positions. Despite his proven track record and two Pro Bowls, Jenkins is impacted by the fact he still has two years left on his current contract. This situation compromises his leverage even as the Packers require him to adjust his playing position due to personnel changes, effectively seeking added security in exchange for his flexibility.
General manager Brian Gutekunst has publicly supported Jenkins, stating that the team values his contributions and is hopeful he returns to practice soon. However, discussions about Jenkins' contract are complicated by his current injury status, which puts him on the NFI list. The Packers have depth on the interior line with young talents and recent signings, potentially leading to a scenario in which Jenkins may not reach a long-term extension, but could secure additional guarantees on his existing deal.
San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Jauan Jennings has similarly found himself at a contractual crossroads after stepping up significantly during last season's injury-plagued period. His impressive numbers last year—77 receptions for 975 yards—have put him in a position to pursue a more lucrative contract as he enters the final year of his deal. Although Jennings has reportedly participated in practice and hasn't formally requested a trade, 49ers general manager John Lynch acknowledged ongoing dialogues regarding a new contract.
Jennings’ standing as a critical member of the receiving corps has gained importance, especially as depth remains a concern due to recent injuries across the group. With fellow receiver Deebo Samuel traded and others dealing with their respective health issues, keeping Jennings satisfied and under contract could prove vital to the 49ers' competitive aspirations this season.
Lastly, Denver Broncos wide receiver Courtland Sutton is navigating a similar landscape as he approaches a pivotal contract year. With consistent production, even amid challenging quarterback situations, Sutton has established himself as a central figure in the Broncos' offense. His desire for a contract extension has persisted since last year, even after the organization adjusted incentives in response to his absence during the offseason program.
Although the precise details of the negotiations remain closely guarded, head coach Sean Payton and general manager George Paton have expressed confidence in reaching a satisfactory agreement. The Broncos' lack of significant additions to the receiver corps underscores Sutton's importance as his contract situation unfolds, with the expectation that a deal will become imminent as the team’s preparations for the season continue.








