Introduction

Spring training is often seen as a mere warm-up for Major League Baseball (MLB), yet it never fails to deliver excitement and intrigue. Players are vying for roster spots, rumors abound, and breakout talents emerge. This year, we tune into eight compelling storylines that invite fans to a game of "Buy or Sell?" From contract negotiations to notable prospect performances, let’s dive into the key issues shaping the early narrative of the 2026 MLB season.

1. Nick Kurtz's Contract Dilemma

Recent reports indicate that the Oakland Athletics have extended a long-term contract offer to Nick Kurtz, the reigning American League Rookie of the Year. After a stellar debut season in which he recorded a 1.002 OPS and 36 home runs, there's pressure for the franchise to secure this rising star.

Buy: The Athletics should aim to lock up Kurtz as he represents a potential franchise cornerstone. At just 22, financial security could be appealing for a player of his caliber, especially with the team’s impending move to Las Vegas.

Sell: On the flip side, Kurtz could command a higher return by waiting for arbitration and free agency, given his exceptional rookie season. With his status as a top-tier talent, he risks little by betting on himself.

2. Konnor Griffin's Bid for Stardom

The Pittsburgh Pirates have their gaze firmly fixed on Konnor Griffin, the consensus No.1 prospect whose power has already turned heads this spring with two explosive home runs, despite limited hits.

Buy: Griffin’s potential is immense, and if he isn’t in the starting shortstop role, that position will likely fall to Nick Gonzales. So why not give him a shot? His upside is tantalizing, drawing comparisons to peak Mike Trout.

Sell: Griffin is still just 19 and has limited minor league experience. The Pirates may be reluctant to rush him to the majors, especially when an extra year of club control looms on the horizon.

3. Kevin McGonigle: The Other Shortstop Prospect

Hot on Griffin's heels is Kevin McGonigle, a talented shortstop also vying for an Opening Day roster spot, this time with the Detroit Tigers. McGonigle's background includes three minor league seasons where he has consistently hit over .300.

Buy: McGonigle's experience is a plus. If he can translate his minor league success to the MLB stage, he could significantly boost the Tigers' infield.

Sell: However, reports suggest that he isn't as highly regarded defensively as Griffin, raising doubts about his fit at shortstop. Tigers management might prefer to wait for a better opportunity.

4. Roki Sasaki's Spring Struggles

For the Los Angeles Dodgers, young pitcher Roki Sasaki has encountered challenges in his transition from rookie starter to effective MLB closer. Sasaki's spring training debut showed promise, yet results were mixed.

Buy: The Dodgers have faith in Sasaki's potential to develop, especially given his history of exceptional performance back in Japan. His velocity is on the rise, hinting at greater things to come.

Sell: Conversely, it may still be too early to categorize him as a guaranteed star in MLB. The concerns around his command need addressing, and his confidence levels could be crucial moving forward.

5. Mike Trout's Return to Center Field

One of MLB's greats, Mike Trout, is set to reclaim his role in center field—a position he enjoyed for the majority of his career—after spending a year in right field and designated hitter roles.

Buy: Trout's comfort and experience in center field are assets, and returning to the position could enhance his performance while preserving his body somewhat.

Sell: Critics might argue that at 34, Trout faces an uphill battle in a demanding position. Age remains an inherent risk that could impede his on-field performance in 2026.

6. Braves' Starting Rotation Dilemma

The Atlanta Braves have entered the offseason with significant holes in their starting rotation. Noticing injuries to Spencer Schwellenbach and Hurston Waldrep leaves them in need of reinforcements.

Buy: With notable free-agent options like Lucas Giolito and Zack Littell still available, it may be wise for the Braves to pursue additional help to solidify their pitching depth.

Sell: However, the team’s financial constraints could limit their options. If they have confidence in pitchers like Bryce Elder and Joey Wentz, they may opt to wait it out, forgoing immediate signings.

7. Giancarlo Stanton's Health Concerns

For the New York Yankees, Giancarlo Stanton faces persistent injury issues after playing a limited game count in 2025 due to elbow complications. Yet, he aims for a fuller season in 2026.

Buy: Assuming a realistic approach, if Stanton suits up for over 100 games next season, that would be a success given his recent history.

Sell: Given Stanton's injury-prone history, optimism could be misplaced. The same risks that curtailed his performance last year might easily recur.

8. Juan Soto's MVP Aspirations

Juan Soto has made it clear: he wants to win the NL MVP, eyeing defending champion Shohei Ohtani as his competition. Soto’s determination is evident as he strives to elevate his game.

Buy: Soto’s blend of power and speed makes him a prime candidate for MVP consideration, as he has consistently ranked among the league's best hitters.

Sell: However, Soto’s defensive shortcomings and a competitive field might hinder his chances of breaking through against Ohtani’s multi-faceted brilliance.

Conclusion

Spring training produces a flurry of storylines that capture the imaginations of fans and analysts alike. As teams evaluate their lineups and set expectations for the season, each of these narratives intertwines with broader implications for player development, contracts, and the overall landscape of MLB. Whether it’s securing contracts, grooming prospects for the future, or unforgettable performances, the excitement of MLB is just beginning.