In the NFL, younger quarterbacks typically have a timeframe of two to three years to demonstrate their viability as starters. Teams often resort to replacing veteran signal-callers if they identify a cheaper option with greater potential. Given these dynamics, starting quarterbacks are under significant pressure annually, and some may face the risk of losing their positions. As the 2025 season approaches, several starting quarterbacks are projected to maintain their current roles but may need to seek opportunities elsewhere if their performances falter. This analysis will explore six quarterbacks who could find themselves on the hot seat in the coming season.

The New Orleans Saints, facing a significant challenge, find themselves $52.3 million over the salary cap. Consequently, front office executives may consider negotiating pay cuts or restructured deals with veteran players. Amidst this financial turmoil, quarterback Derek Carr has intensified scrutiny regarding his future with remarks indicating a refusal to accept a reduced salary. "I wouldn't take a pay cut. Yeah, I wouldn't do that. Especially with what I put on tape," Carr stated, while expressing his willingness to restructure his contract. In two seasons with the Saints, Carr has posted impressive statistics, including 6,023 passing yards, 40 touchdowns, and 13 interceptions, though his performance has been scrutinized due to injury setbacks and a midseason slump. With new coaching staff on the horizon, Carr may face a critical evaluation of his contributions in 2025, particularly if the team opts for a major roster overhaul.

Arizona Cardinals head coach Jonathan Gannon expressed confidence in Kyler Murray's role for the 2025 season, stating he is "100 percent" committed to the quarterback. However, Murray's contract situation remains precarious, as he enters the fourth year of a deal that lacks guaranteed money beyond 2025. Despite leading the Cardinals' passing attack in 2024, Murray's performance has raised questions. He acknowledged struggles with his connection to rookie wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr., which could impact offensive cohesion. For Murray to secure a long-term deal, he must showcase improvement during the upcoming season. Additionally, Gannon's own job security may influence how the team addresses Murray's future if the offense fails to thrive in 2025.

The Indianapolis Colts demonstrated mounting impatience with quarterback Anthony Richardson during the previous season, as he was benched for Joe Flacco after a series of inconsistent performances. General manager Chris Ballard characterized Richardson's struggles as a moment of crisis that necessitated a timeout to regain poise. Given Richardson's limited experience, having started only 15 games thus far, there remains considerable potential for growth. However, the Colts' recent playoff absences put pressure on both Ballard and head coach Shane Steichen as they seek immediate improvement. Ballard indicated the need for competition at the quarterback position, which could reshape Richardson's status for the 2025 season. He will be compelled to stay healthy and demonstrate marked progress to maintain his starting role.

Seattle Seahawks head coach Mike Macdonald has left the possibility open for changes at quarterback, offering a measured endorsement of Geno Smith's performance. His remarks suggest that while Smith may remain the best option for the team's current needs, offseason activities, including free agency and trades, could prompt organizational shifts. With one year remaining on Smith's deal and no guarantee of an extension, he faces considerable pressure to exceed previous passing statistics of 4,320 yards, 21 touchdowns, and 15 interceptions. For Smith, the need to rebound from a season marked by turnovers and operational inconsistencies is paramount. As he approaches his 35th year, failing to impress the coaching staff could lead to a search for new options in the upcoming season.

Tua Tagovailoa finds himself confronting challenges on multiple fronts as he aims to solidify his role heading into the 2025 season. His performance against playoff-caliber teams has been underwhelming, with seven touchdowns balanced by seven interceptions in crucial matchups throughout 2024. Additionally, Tagovailoa's injury history raises concerns regarding his ability to remain healthy. He has struggled with concussions and missed games due to injuries, which complicates the Dolphins' decision-making regarding their quarterback situation. Should Tagovailoa continue to face health challenges or deliver uninspiring performances, Miami could explore alternative options, including drafting a quarterback or enhancing the backup position in the offseason.

In his inaugural season as head coach, Dave Canales made a notable decision by benching Bryce Young, the 2023 No. 1 overall pick, in Week 3. This move allowed veteran Andy Dalton to take the reins for five consecutive games. Following an injury to Dalton, Young resumed his starting role and demonstrated considerable improvement, closing the season with seven touchdown passes while maintaining an unblemished interception ratio. Notably, with Dalton's contract expiring in March and only undrafted rookie Jack Plummer under contract for 2025, Young appears set to continue as the Panthers' starter. Nevertheless, he must prove himself to the new coaching staff that inherited him and demonstrate why he was selected first overall in 2023. The pressure to perform will be evident as he navigates his sophomore season.