Reflecting on Misguided Predictions as 2025 Season Winds Down

As the 2025 regular season approaches its conclusion, it’s a perfect time to revisit those preseason predictions that turned out to be off the mark. While it's easy to celebrate the hits, acknowledging the misses provides insight into the dynamics of major league baseball.

Braves' Disappointing Season

Last year, the Atlanta Braves managed to win 89 games under challenging circumstances, barely scraping into the postseason. Expectations were high for the current season, with many anticipating they would contend fiercely with the Dodgers for dominance in the National League. However, the reality is starkly different as they find themselves trailing not only the Philadelphia Phillies and New York Mets but also the Miami Marlins in the NL East.

Despite an impressive comeback from Ronald Acuña Jr. following a serious injury, the team has suffered from underperformances and injuries. Spencer Strider is struggling with a 5.24 ERA after major elbow surgery, while closer Raisel Iglesias and Ozzie Albies continue to experience disappointing seasons. The offseason will bring challenges for president of baseball operations Alex Anthopoulos as key players like Iglesias and Ozuna approach free agency.

Adley Rutschman's Stalling Career

Adley Rutschman, who appeared to be asserting himself as one of the premier catchers after back-to-back All-Star appearances, has faced a decline. His performance in the second half of 2024 slumped significantly, and the downward trend continues into 2025 with just a .227 batting average and .684 OPS.

This downturn raises questions about his future with the Baltimore Orioles. Rutschman, once seen as a franchise cornerstone, may now be viewed as a candidate for a change of scenery, especially given his two remaining years of team control.

Milwaukee Brewers' Continued Success

The Milwaukee Brewers were expected to falter this season following the loss of key players like Corbin Burnes and Willy Adames. Countering those predictions, however, the Brewers have defied expectations and currently boast the best record in baseball. After a shaky start, they have rebounded impressively, with vital contributions from players like Trevor Megill and Freddy Peralta, solidifying Pat Murphy’s management as a successful transition.

Giancarlo Stanton's Resurgence

In a surprising turn of events, Giancarlo Stanton's comeback after his severe elbow injuries has showcased his enduring prowess. Since returning in mid-June, he has been a key contributor with a .306 batting average and 14 home runs, proving skepticism wrong.

Texas Rangers and Arizona Diamondbacks’ Disappointments

Once predicted to shine, the Texas Rangers find themselves struggling below .500. Despite solid performances from their starting pitchers, the team’s offensive lineup has failed to deliver, leading to a significant crossroads for GM Chris Young.

Similarly, the Arizona Diamondbacks, who appeared poised for success after their World Series run, have faltered. With significant injuries and a disappointing record of 61-66, they face challenges ahead, particularly with uncertainties surrounding their pitching staff as the offseason approaches.

As the season nears its end, it’s evident that the unpredictability of baseball can turn expectations upside down, creating fascinating narratives and challenges for fans and teams alike.