As the 2024 NFL campaign approaches, questions surrounding the Pittsburgh Steelers' starting quarterback position have intensified. Amid growing concerns from the fanbase about the team's recent performance, head coach Mike Tomlin has faced scrutiny regarding the effectiveness of his leadership. A record of 38-29-1 over the past four seasons falls notably short of the franchise's historical success, particularly its Super Bowl credentials. However, attributing the team's mediocrity solely to Tomlin's coaching may overlook a more significant factor: the retirement of franchise quarterback Ben Roethlisberger. In a league where the success of a franchise often hinges on having a standout quarterback, the Steelers find themselves in search of a reliable replacement. Yet, the alternatives available for the upcoming season appear lackluster.

Among the potential candidates is Skyler Thompson, who brings a measure of starting experience from his time with the Miami Dolphins. The seventh-round draft pick from 2022 started three games as a rookie due to injuries to more established quarterbacks, Tua Tagovailoa and Teddy Bridgewater. However, Thompson's performance in those starts, including a postseason game against the Buffalo Bills where he completed only 40% of his passes, raises doubts about his readiness to step into a significant role with the Steelers. Despite a challenging path ahead, Thompson may find himself competing for a spot within the quarterback room, although he is unlikely to break into the top ranks unless the team opts for further acquisitions.

As the uncertainty lingers, one name looms large: Aaron Rodgers. The future Hall of Famer's potential signing by the Steelers has sparked considerable speculation. While the organization awaits Rodgers' decision, returning quarterback Mason Rudolph is approaching the offseason with the mindset of a starter. With 13 career starts under his belt, Rudolph's familiarity with the team and coaching staff is an advantage. However, his track record falls short of convincing anyone he is the definitive answer at quarterback. Comments from Steelers linebacker Alex Highsmith reflect the mixed sentiments within the locker room, highlighting Rodgers' prestige while minimizing potential distractions. While the allure of acquiring an established veteran like Rodgers exists, the Steelers may favor other options. For instance, Kirk Cousins could present a more stable presence without the drama that often accompanies Rodgers.