As the 2024 NFL season approaches, the Pittsburgh Steelers continue their search for a starting quarterback, a task that has become increasingly pressing. The franchise, historically known for its excellence, has struggled to maintain its standards since the retirement of Ben Roethlisberger. The organization, under head coach Mike Tomlin, has faced scrutiny, especially given a 38-29-1 record over the past four seasons, which falls short of the legacy that once included multiple Super Bowl victories.

Currently, speculation surrounds potential signings, particularly with Aaron Rodgers. The Steelers await a final decision from the 41-year-old veteran, yet the franchise remains open to other options. Recently drafted Skyler Thompson, who brings limited starting experience from his time with the Miami Dolphins, faces significant competition to secure a spot in the Steelers' quarterback rotation. Though Thompson appeared in three games for Miami, including a playoff outing, his performance has not positioned him as a frontrunner for a pivotal role in Pittsburgh's plans.

As it stands, Mason Rudolph, who previously played for the Steelers, is preparing as though he will be the team's starter, despite the uncertainty surrounding the quarterback position. Rudolph, who has had minimal success in his earlier career with Pittsburgh and a brief stint with the Tennessee Titans, knows that the competition may intensify if the Steelers acquire another experienced quarterback. He expressed confidence in his preparation while maintaining a clear focus on team improvement. Meanwhile, the potential arrival of Rodgers looms large, drawing mixed opinions, including notable skepticism from former Steelers quarterback Terry Bradshaw, who questioned the feasibility and benefits of signing a veteran needing to rehabilitate his career. Bradshaw emphasized that the Steelers should consider whether adding another veteran could disrupt locker room cohesion, particularly when alternatives like Kirk Cousins might provide the leadership and skill set needed without the associated drama.

The Steelers find themselves at a critical juncture, teetering between mediocrity and the pursuit of high-level competition. Underperforming quarterback play has historically hampered the team’s potential to excel in the playoffs, leaving them unable to establish themselves firmly within the AFC landscape dominated by quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen. Young talents like Will Howard, drafted in the sixth round, could represent the fresh start the franchise needs, provided he develops and adapts quickly. Analysts highlight Howard's athleticism and potential, suggesting that he could either become a surprising success or lead the team into a rebuild that could generate higher draft picks in the approaching seasons. The decisions made in this offseason will shape the Steelers’ trajectory for years to come.