The conclusion of the NHL season often brings with it several head coaching vacancies, and the 2024-25 season has presented one of the highest numbers in recent years. Eight teams entered the offseason on the lookout for new leadership behind the bench, and the process to fill these roles is progressing rapidly, with five teams having already made selections. While the Boston Bruins, Pittsburgh Penguins, and Seattle Kraken finalize their own coaching searches, it is worthwhile to assess the recent hires that have taken place in the last few weeks and consider which remaining franchises may later regret their choices.

In a move that was anticipated, the Chicago Blackhawks appointed former Detroit Red Wings coach Jeff Blashill. Having been dismissed by the Red Wings in April 2022 after a seven-year tenure focused on rebuilding, Blashill brings a robust background in player development, with coaching experience spanning the USHL, NCAA, and AHL prior to his time in Detroit. Recently, he spent three years as an assistant under acclaimed coach Jon Cooper in Tampa Bay, during which he refined his resume for another opportunity in the NHL. The Blackhawks have faced challenges, cycling through four different first-year head coaches since 2018. With Blashill's extensive experience in both player development and NHL rebuilds, he is well-positioned to steer the team through its ongoing rebuilding phase. Current expectations are manageable, allowing the Blackhawks time to re-establish themselves as contenders in the playoffs.

The New York Rangers made headlines by hiring Mike Sullivan, a seasoned coach with a track record of success. Sullivan's previous role with the Pittsburgh Penguins spanned over a decade, leading to eight playoff appearances and back-to-back Stanley Cups. The decision to bring him on board was facilitated by General Manager Chris Drury's longstanding connections to Sullivan, including coaching in USA Hockey together. The Rangers secured Sullivan's services shortly after he parted ways with the Penguins, signing him to a five-year contract with an average annual value of $6.5 million, making him the highest-paid coach in NHL history. As the Rangers seek to regain their competitive edge, Sullivan's experience with established cores like those in Pittsburgh could prove crucial.

Rick Tocchet, known for his winning personality and coaching prowess, joins the Philadelphia Flyers under challenging circumstances. Though he has a reputation for connecting with players, having won the Jack Adams Award for his successful year with the Vancouver Canucks, his new role comes with substantial expectations. Tocchet's history with the Flyers, including being a franchise legend, suggests familiarity that could benefit the team. However, while the potential for success is high, there are also risks involved. Should the team struggle, the pressure associated with Tocchet's legacy may create an environment of heightened expectations. In contrast, the success of similar hires, such as Rod Brind'Amour with the Carolina Hurricanes, shows it is possible to transition effectively into a challenging role, and Tocchet is expected to strive for a similar outcome in Philadelphia.

In Vancouver, the Canucks opted to promote assistant coach Shawn Foote following the departure of Tocchet. This decision arrives after a tumultuous season for the franchise, noted for its attempts to revitalize its play. Foote has been part of the coaching structure that has sought improvements in defensive play, particularly under the guidance of Tocchet. While some observers may view the promotion of an internal candidate as a non-committal choice, it appears Foote's understanding of the players and the team's systems could foster stability amid ongoing changes. Nevertheless, skepticism exists regarding the overall direction of the Canucks' front office, raising questions about the future concerning key players like Quinn Hughes. The success of the promotion may hinge on maintaining a balanced environment as the team looks to emerge from a rough patch.