At the conclusion of the NHL season, it is common to see a number of head coaching vacancies, but the 2024-25 season has resulted in an unprecedented number of open positions. Eight teams entered the offseason in search of new head coaches, and the hiring process has progressed rapidly, with five teams already making appointments. As organizations such as the Boston Bruins, Pittsburgh Penguins, and Seattle Kraken continue their coaching searches, it is worth assessing the coaching hires made thus far. Which candidates will the remaining teams regret missing out on?

One notable hire came from the Chicago Blackhawks, who appointed former Detroit Red Wings coach Jeff Blashill. This decision was expected, given Blashill's extensive coaching background, which includes notable roles in the USHL, NCAA, and AHL before stepping in to lead the Red Wings during their rebuilding phase. After spending three seasons as an assistant under esteemed coach Jon Cooper with the Tampa Bay Lightning, Blashill acquired valuable experience that will aid in guiding the Blackhawks through their current rebuild. With a lack of immediate pressure for success, as the Blackhawks are not anticipated to compete for playoff spots in the near future, this hire appears to prioritize long-term development over immediate results.

The New York Rangers made headlines by hiring Mike Sullivan, previously with the Pittsburgh Penguins, in what appears to be a significant step forward for the franchise. Sullivan, who signed a five-year contract valued at $6.5 million AAV, has a decorated history that includes multiple playoff appearances and two Stanley Cup championships. His familiarity with established core teams looking to achieve championships aligns with the Rangers' aspirations to return to competitiveness. With the Penguins recently missing the playoffs, both parties seemed ready for a change, making Sullivan's appointment a critical move for the Rangers as they aim to turn around their fortunes.

Rick Tocchet, another coaching figure, has garnered considerable admiration as both a personality and a coach. After earning the Jack Adams Award for his successful stint with the Vancouver Canucks, Tocchet’s experience and close ties to the Philadelphia Flyers as a former player enhance his credibility. This hiring introduces a layer of complexity, as Tocchet's reputation must now translate into success with a Flyers team that has been struggling in recent seasons. While admirers of Tocchet recognize the potential for revival, there are inherent risks associated with the high expectations attached to hiring a franchise legend in a challenging scenario.

Meanwhile, the Canucks have promoted assistant coach Adam Foote to head coach, a move that was met with mixed reactions. Foote's familiarity with the team’s structure, particularly on the defensive side, lends stability to a franchise that has faced significant challenges. While some may view this hiring as a default option rather than a strategic choice, Foote's prior role in improving the defense indicates a commitment to continuity. However, concerns linger regarding the front office's credibility in making effective choices, particularly in how they manage key players like Quinn Hughes, and the potential implications of the organization's decisions.