The conclusion of the NHL season often results in several head coaching vacancies, and the 2024-25 offseason has seen an unprecedented number of openings. Eight teams have entered this offseason seeking new leadership behind the bench, and the hiring process has been rapid, with five teams already securing new coaches. As the Boston Bruins, Pittsburgh Penguins, and Seattle Kraken finalize their coaching searches, an evaluation of the recently appointed coaches provides insight into the new directions these franchises may take.

Grade: B. The Chicago Blackhawks made a notable decision by hiring former Detroit Red Wings coach Jeff Blashill. Blashill, who was let go from the Red Wings in April 2022 after overseeing a lengthy rebuild, possesses a solid background in player development. His coaching career has spanned various leagues, including the USHL, NCAA, and AHL, before he took over in Detroit prior to the 2015-16 season. Most recently, Blashill honed his skills under renowned head coach Jon Cooper during his tenure with the Tampa Bay Lightning. With the Blackhawks having cycled through four different first-year NHL head coaches since 2018, Blashill’s experience with player development and rebuilding efforts positions him as a suitable choice to guide the team through its current challenges. As the Blackhawks embark on a long-term rebuilding plan, expectations for immediate success are low, giving Blashill the opportunity to establish a foundation without undue pressure.

Grade: A+. The New York Rangers took a significant step forward by hiring Mike Sullivan amidst tumultuous conditions last season. General Manager Chris Drury utilized longstanding connections to bring Sullivan on board, with both individuals having history with Boston University and USA Hockey. Sullivan's swift departure from the Pittsburgh Penguins was quickly followed by his signing with the Rangers, where he secured a five-year contract worth an average annual value of $6.5 million, positioning him as the highest-paid coach in NHL history. Having led the Penguins through ten seasons that included two Stanley Cup victories, Sullivan brings substantive experience and a proven record of success. The Rangers, looking to reclaim their competitive edge, have embraced the decision, believing Sullivan can revitalize the franchise and guide them back to the playoffs.

Grade: B. The hiring of Rick Tocchet by the Philadelphia Flyers garnered positive sentiments from fans and analysts alike. Tocchet, who earned the Jack Adams Award during his successful term with the Vancouver Canucks, is well-regarded for his ability to connect with players. His history with the Flyers as a player solidifies his status within the organization, and General Manager Danny Briere's prior relationship with Tocchet may enhance collaborative efforts moving forward. While the potential for Tocchet to lead the team to a successful turnaround exists, there are also risks associated with imposing high expectations on a franchise legend expected to navigate a difficult rebuilding process. Nevertheless, Tocchet’s prior experience with transforming teams reinforces his suitability for the role, and there is optimism regarding his ability to guide the Flyers towards a resurgence in competitiveness.

Grade: B-. The Vancouver Canucks have drawn scrutiny in recent seasons, principally due to inconsistency and on-ice struggles. The organization, under new leadership, has opted to promote from within by naming assistant coach Adam Foote as the head coach following Tocchet's departure. While assistant promotions often draw mixed reactions, Foote's familiarity with the existing roster, particularly his rapport with star defenseman Quinn Hughes, may provide continuity during a period of transition. The Canucks are aiming to build on the positive defensive framework established under Tocchet, which has the potential to guide them out of their recent challenges. However, doubts persist regarding the management’s decision-making, and speculation surrounding the dynamics of player relationships within the organization continues to cloud the progression of their rebuilding efforts.