Exploring the MLB Free-Agent Relief Pitcher Market
The MLB free-agent market for relief pitchers has been notably quiet, with only 16 relievers securing major league contracts so far. However, recent developments suggest a possible increase in activity. Chris Martin has recently signed, and reports indicate that Tanner Scott may command around $20 million per year in a multiyear deal. This situation highlights the need to assess the most promising landing spots for the top eight remaining relievers, a task that combines pairing players with interested teams while also exploring creative speculations.
Paul Sewald, aged 34, presents an interesting case. After a challenging season in Arizona where injuries hampered his performance, he struggled to maintain his role as the closer for the Diamondbacks. Sewald had an ERA of 4.31 over 42 games in 2024. The Detroit Tigers emerge as a fitting destination for him, as Comerica Park is known for its difficulty for hitters, particularly benefiting a pitcher like Sewald, who has a history of platoon splits and has shown considerable strikeout potential in previous years.
At 33 years old, Kyle Finnegan enjoyed an All-Star season with the Washington Nationals, saving 38 games in 2024, yet was non-tendered due to concerns about his hittability. Reports suggest that the Chicago Cubs are interested in Finnegan, who could provide insurance at closer if Porter Hodge does not replicate his past success. Finnegan's ability to pitch effectively against lefties with his splitter makes him an appealing option for the Cubs as they seek bullpen depth.
David Robertson, who turns 39, is looking for a strong conclusion to his career. His effectiveness remains a testament to his skills, highlighted by his 3.00 ERA over 68 games in 2024. With a significant portion of his career spent with the New York Yankees, a return to the Bronx could serve as a fitting capstone for Robertson's tenure in Major League Baseball. Following trades for other relievers, the Yankees may show interest in solving their bullpen needs with the addition of Robertson.
Kenley Jansen, now 37, continues to prove his prowess with a record of 447 career saves. Despite a rocky finish in Boston, he still possesses one of the most effective cutters in the game, allowing opponents to hit just .215 against it last season. The Toronto Blue Jays are thought to be a suitable fit for Jansen given their struggling bullpen performance in 2024. His experience in the American League East would provide the Blue Jays with a seasoned option in high-pressure situations.
Kirby Yates, also 37, has been a stellar performer, showcasing an impressive 1.17 ERA over 61 games. His recent success positions him as an ideal candidate for a team like the Boston Red Sox, who are seeking high-strikeout pitchers. Yates fits the profile that Red Sox executives are looking for, particularly with their emphasis on swing-and-miss capability in the bullpen.
At 32 years old, Carlos Estévez had a stellar 2024 season, finishing with a 2.45 ERA across 54 games. The Arizona Diamondbacks are actively seeking additional late-inning relievers, potentially making Estévez, with his sub-.200 batting average against, a critical addition to their bullpen mix. While the Diamondbacks have not directly pursued him, their need for quality arms in support of their current setup is evident.
Jeff Hoffman, 32, has expressed interest in free agency that parallels Clay Holmes' lucrative contract signed with the New York Mets. Hoffman, with a recent 2.17 ERA over 68 appearances, has been gunning for a rotation spot, which could lead teams like the Atlanta Braves to take a chance on him. Historically, the Braves have demonstrated a willingness to transition relievers to starting roles, which could similarly apply to Hoffman as they look to fill gaps left by departing pitchers.
Finally, Tanner Scott, aged 30, has emerged as one of the most effective relievers in the league, boasting a 1.75 ERA in 72 games in 2024. His ability to keep hitters in check has drawn attention from several franchises, notably the New York Mets, who need a reliable left-handed option in their bullpen. Securing Scott could bolster their late-game strategy and provide valuable depth as they aim to compete at the highest level.