As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, Colorado's Shedeur Sanders and Miami's Cam Ward are anticipated to be among the top-five selections, with some projections suggesting they could be the first and second overall picks. However, not all quarterback prospects are evaluated equally. Historically, the perception of quarterback talent has varied; for instance, Andrew Luck was viewed drastically different from Baker Mayfield, despite both being selected with the first overall pick. The quarterback position continues to hold the highest value due to its significance in the game, yet not all top quarterback prospects are necessarily elite talents. The incoming 2025 class presents a more uncertain top tier compared to previous years, potentially benefiting Sanders and Ward.

To contextualize their standing among recent quarterback classes, the Bleacher Report Scouting Department, comprising Nate Tice, Derrick Klassen, and Dame Parson, has evaluated quarterback prospects since the 2021 draft cycle. Their grading has allowed for a comparative analysis of Sanders and Ward against quarterbacks from the last four years, providing a clearer understanding of their potential impact in the NFL. The grading scale employed by the Scouting Department includes categories from generational talent to developmental prospects, thus offering insights into the perceived value of incoming quarterbacks.

Shedeur Sanders, regarded as a potential top choice for the upcoming draft, carries with him several strengths and weaknesses that could affect his draft stock and subsequent professional success. He demonstrated exceptional accuracy and a strong presence on the field while leading the Jackson State Tigers and Colorado Buffaloes, but there are concerns regarding his ability to handle pressure and maintain anticipation in his throws. Meanwhile, Cam Ward's journey from the FCS level to Miami has solidified his status as a leading prospect for 2025. Ward's impressive arm talent and mobility provide him with the tools necessary for success in the NFL, though questions remain regarding his decision-making under pressure.

Comparing recent quarterback performances, the 2022 class underwhelmed, highlighted by Brock Purdy’s emergence as a legitimate starter after being selected last. Desmond Ridder, perceived as the best among a struggling group, has faced challenges in his development, leading the Atlanta Falcons to seek other options, including veteran acquisitions. Anthony Richardson’s raw talent offers immense upside, yet his lack of refinement has hampered his progress. Each prospect introduces a unique set of skills and potential pitfalls, further complicating the evaluation process as teams prepare for the upcoming draft.