Calming Preseason Hype: Observations from NFL Organized Team Activities

As NFL organized team activities continue, speculation and overreactions from media and fanbases are becoming increasingly prevalent. Among the notable performances reported is that of Shedeur Sanders, who completed seven of nine passes with three touchdowns and no interceptions during drills with the Cleveland Browns. This has led some to prematurely label the rookie fifth-round pick as the frontrunner in a competitive quarterback battle. While excitement surrounding a talented newcomer is understandable, it is important to remember that these early performances are not indicative of regular-season success. Sanders still has considerable development ahead, particularly in refining his timing and awareness in the pocket.
In other news, rookie second overall pick Travis Hunter, who initially trained primarily on offense, has begun integrating with the Jacksonville Jaguars' defense. Transitioning from meetings to on-field work so quickly is encouraging, and it's natural for Jaguars fans to feel optimistic. However, playing effectively at both offensive and defensive positions has proven challenging, with very few players managing to sustain success in such dual roles over the past century. It is likely that Hunter's current involvement will serve more as an experimental phase rather than a long-term strategy throughout his career.
Ladd McConkey has emerged as a key target for Justin Herbert in the 2024 season, raising questions about how their connection might evolve in McConkey's sophomore campaign. The duo appears to be developing good chemistry this offseason, but circumstances warrant caution. With opposing defenses focusing more on the Chargers' offense than their defense, Los Angeles will need to effectively incorporate rookie Tre Harris into their plans. Additionally, setbacks due to injuries could hinder McConkey’s potential impact, which reflects a concern given the competitive nature of the Chargers' roster.
Roman Wilson, a third-round pick in 2024, is reportedly performing well in offseason activities for the Pittsburgh Steelers, an encouraging development considering the team’s need for additional support alongside DK Metcalf. Wilson has demonstrated improvements in strength and size during practices; however, skepticism remains due to his history of injuries and his smaller frame. Any changes to his physique must not compromise his agility, particularly given uncertainties surrounding the Steelers' quarterback situation, which is expected to favor Metcalf throughout the 2025 campaign.
Meanwhile, No. 1 overall pick Cam Ward struggled during practice, completing only three of seven attempts in team drills while navigating a competitive quarterback landscape with Will Levis still in play for the Tennessee Titans. As both quarterbacks alternate reps, it is crucial to avoid drawing definitive conclusions based on limited practices, as expectations suggest that a top draft pick is likely to start early in his career, akin to previous first-round selections like Trevor Lawrence, Bryce Young, and Caleb Williams.
The Green Bay Packers have made headlines by having their first-round wide receiver, Golden, take first-team reps at organized team activities. This is a positive sign of his capabilities as the Packers boast significant depth at the receiver position. Reports highlight Golden's smooth route-running during Wednesday's session, suggesting he is living up to his draft status. Nevertheless, it is essential to recognize that early placements with first team units might simply be a way for coaches to evaluate players who may not yet be fully ready for the demands of the regular season. Previous mental lapses experienced by Golden during his college career could pose challenges as he competes with other talented receivers.
Rookie second-round pick Tyler Shough has captured attention with impressive performances; similarly, Spencer Rattler has attracted interest during organized team activities. Despite the excitement surrounding Rattler's progress, questions linger regarding his previous struggles with accuracy during his rookie season. The same cautious approach should apply to Shough, who may face obstacles as he attempts to minimize mistakes early in his career.
Additionally, Drake Maye has faced challenges, throwing interceptions and witnessing the New England Patriots' offense struggle with cohesion amid major offensive line changes. While minor setbacks are expected, the Patriots' defense, led by Christian Gonzalez, appears to be coming together nicely. Given Maye's promising rookie season and the support available to him, there is optimism that the team can address and resolve these early-season issues.
Lastly, quarterback J.J. McCarthy has demonstrated accuracy and confidence during workouts, although he is still regarded as a player with room for growth after a lackluster inaugural season. It is crucial to assess the progress he makes in adapting to high-pressure situations as he prepares for the 2025 campaign. Meanwhile, the Dallas Cowboys find themselves in a precarious situation with star linebacker Micah Parsons absent from organized team activities due to contract extension negotiations. Cowboys fans may feel a swell of frustration, yet history shows that organizations typically navigate similar challenges without panic, underscoring the importance of patience in such circumstances.








