A Thorough Review of the 2019 MLB Draft Class

As we touch on another year of reflection, it's time to assess the 2019 MLB Draft class. A few years back, Bleacher Report emphasized that a minimum of six years is essential to evaluate a draft class effectively. This duration allows prospects ample time to progress through the minor leagues and make their mark in the majors.

Overall, the 2019 draft has emerged as one of the most promising classes in recent memory. Notable first-round picks like Adley Rutschman (No. 1) and Bobby Witt Jr. (No. 2) have developed into cornerstones for their respective franchises. In addition, several first-round selections including Riley Greene (No. 5), CJ Abrams (No. 6), Corbin Carroll (No. 16), George Kirby (No. 20), and Michael Busch (No. 31) have shown significant talent at the big league level.

Highlighting Standouts and Setbacks

Moreover, players taken outside the first round have made headlines, such as Gunnar Henderson (second round, No. 42 overall) and Hunter Brown (fifth round, No. 166 overall), both rising to All-Star status. Even Kerry Carpenter, drafted in the 19th round at No. 562, has proven to be a diamond in the rough.

Each team’s draft class received grades from A to F, based on the MLB talent produced, performance of first-round picks, and utilization of prospects in trades. For instance, the Arizona Diamondbacks received an 'A' grade, with Corbin Carroll quickly becoming a franchise player after winning the 2023 NL Rookie of the Year.

Conversely, the Oakland Athletics' draft class is graded an 'F' despite the presence of first-round pick Logan Davidson, who has struggled to fulfill expectations. Only five players from this draft class have reached the majors, contributing a combined low WAR.

The Baltimore Orioles experienced major success with Adley Rutschman and Gunnar Henderson, earning an 'A' grade as they compiled an impressive total of 11 All-Stars from the 2019 draft.

This overview of the 2019 draft illustrates a mixed landscape of outcomes. The successes highlight the potential of solid drafting in rebuilding franchises, while the failures remind us of the uncertainties that come with prospect evaluation.