Introduction

The MLB offseason is bustling with anticipation as marquee names like Kyle Tucker and Bo Bichette weigh their options. However, amidst the clamor, a group of underrated free agents could prove to be valuable assets for teams looking to bolster their rosters for the 2026 season. Bleacher Report's Joel Reuter recently highlighted these lesser-known talents, who might just be waiting for the right call.

Key Underrated Free Agents

While some players on Reuter's top 25 free agent board are making headlines, others might provide excellent opportunities for teams in need. Let’s explore some intriguing, under-the-radar options:

Nick Madrigal

The 28-year-old second baseman has struggled with injuries but remains a prolific contact hitter. With a career average that shines in terms of plate discipline, he could be a versatile backup if signed.

Jordan Montgomery

After undergoing Tommy John surgery, Montgomery is looking to make a comeback. Teams might find value in what could be a low-cost option, providing depth in the latter part of the 2026 season.

Michael Toglia

Once a promising first-round draft pick, Toglia's power potential is evident from his minor league performance. Searching teams could find a fit to address first base concerns.

José Urquidy

After a long injury recovery, Urquidy's historical performance suggests he could bounce back dramatically, making him a worthy gamble for any team looking for pitching help.

Victor Caratini

As a solid defensive catcher who can also serve as a DH, Caratini is an appealing target, especially for teams looking to strengthen their bench behind the plate.

Zach Eflin

Despite a disappointing 2025 marred by injuries, Eflin's previous strong performances suggest he may still be able to contribute significantly once healthy.

Rhys Hoskins

Young enough to have a rebound season, Hoskins was a former standout for the Phillies. His ability to hit for power makes him a candidate for teams needing first base options.

Michael Kopech

A reliever with significant strikeout capability, Kopech’s recent struggles due to injuries may have pushed him off teams' radar, but his recent performance suggests he could be a valuable late-inning option.

Nathaniel Lowe

After a strange 2025 season, Lowe's offensive capability warrants attention, especially for teams looking for a left-handed hitter who can perform against righties.

Yoán Moncada

Moncada's substantial talent is overshadowed by his injury history. However, if he can remain healthy, he has the potential to far exceed his recent one-year contract value.

Marcell Ozuna

Coming off a challenging season, Ozuna still possesses the talent to be a formidable slugger, making him a potential bargain for teams in search of offensive depth.

Max Scherzer

Although showing signs of decline and injury issues, the legendary right-hander remains a captivating option as he aims to add to his impressive career strikeout total.

Conclusion

As the MLB free agency period unfolds, these underrated players represent potential value additions for teams looking to make an impact without breaking the bank. Each of these talents offers distinct skills that could shine with the right opportunities come the 2026 season.