Introduction

The New York Yankees have long enjoyed a rich history of success at the shortstop position, largely thanks to legends like Derek Jeter and standout performances from players like Didi Gregorius. However, the 2020s have brought a stark contrast, as the team now finds itself among the bottom four in Wins Above Replacement (WAR) for shortstops. This disappointing trend raises questions about Anthony Volpe, the club's young shortstop who has become a focal point of frustration for fans.

The Rise and Current Struggles of Volpe

When the Yankees appointed Anthony Volpe as their starting shortstop in 2023, expectations were high. Comparisons to Derek Jeter were inevitable, given the hype surrounding the young talent. However, despite hitting 21 home runs as a rookie, Volpe's performance has faltered. His transition to a flatter swing in 2024 did not yield the desired results—instead, he saw a modest OBP increase paired with a notable decrease in slugging percentage.

Volpe's defensive woes have also surged, as he currently leads the American League with 18 errors. This season, he has also faced criticism from fans following closely contested games, particularly during a recent series against the Boston Red Sox where significant mistakes contributed to his team's struggle.

Managerial Decisions and Fan Frustration

The discontent among fans has been palpable, with many questioning the Yankees' decision to stand by Volpe amidst his evident decline. Manager Aaron Boone's comments and actions regarding Volpe have added fuel to the fire, especially when he publicly defended the player's errors and then swiftly benched him shortly thereafter.

As the season progresses, Boone’s inability to incorporate tough love into his management style has become a point of contention, with critics suggesting that a lack of accountability may be hindering Volpe's development. Furthermore, the Yankees' front office, led by Brian Cashman, faces scrutiny for not taking more decisive action to address Volpe's struggles.

Looking Ahead: Possible Solutions for the Yankees

While the Yankees have found some success recently, their struggles at shortstop highlight a critical issue that needs addressing. Moving forward, several options could help alleviate the burden on Volpe: transitioning him to a secondary role and introducing another player, José Caballero, as a starting shortstop could be an immediate fix. In the long-term, a structured Performance Improvement Plan may be necessary to rebuild Volpe's confidence and skills.

Ultimately, the Yankees must confront their approach—and whether sticking to unproven strategies is genuinely working for the organization's future. With the upcoming offseason, significant changes may be on the horizon whether it's in player development or management approaches.