In Major League Baseball (MLB), one of the most critical factors in determining a player's trade value is whether they are perceived as a temporary rental or if they are under club control beyond the current season. Rental players often draw significant attention for their immediate impact, yet it is the controllable non-rentals that tend to yield substantial returns for teams in rebuilding phases needing fresh talent. This analysis focuses on the top 25 non-rental players on the 2025 MLB trade market, with rankings informed by their current performance, anticipated impact, remaining club control, and probability of being traded.

To begin, several players have recently circulated in trade rumors but are viewed as likely to remain with their current teams, at least through the trade deadline. These players include notable pitchers and hitters such as Félix Bautista (Bal), Emmanuel Clase (Cle), and Ozzie Albies (Atl), among others. While speculation is commonplace in trades, the expectation is that these players will stay put, though offseason deals may still be contemplated.

The list ranks players beginning with Andrew Benintendi of the Chicago White Sox. With a contract totaling $17.1 million owed for 2026 and $15.1 million for 2027, the White Sox are reportedly willing to reduce Benintendi's salary to facilitate a trade. As a seasoned veteran, his 103 OPS+ and 11 home runs this season make him a desirable asset in a market lacking in offensive strength, potentially attracting interest from several teams.