In Major League Baseball (MLB), one of the most critical elements when assessing a player's trade value is determining whether they are merely a short-term rental for the final weeks of the season or if they are under club control beyond the current campaign. While rental players often serve as obvious trade chips, controllable non-rentals significantly impact rebuilding teams seeking an influx of young talent. This article focuses on non-rental players in the 2025 MLB trade market, highlighting the top 25 ranked based on performance, potential impact, club control, and likelihood of being traded.

Several players have emerged as speculative trade topics; however, the expectation is that they will remain with their current teams for the time being. Among these are pitchers such as Félix Bautista from Baltimore, Emmanuel Clase from Cleveland, and Kyle Freeland from Colorado, along with hitters like Ozzie Albies of Atlanta and Nolan Arenado from St. Louis. Although there may be interest in these players, the likelihood of them being dealt in the near term appears low, although offseason trades remain possible.

Now, turning to the top-ranked non-rental trade candidates, the discussions begin with Andrew Benintendi from the Chicago White Sox. Despite the financial strain associated with his contract, the White Sox may be willing to offset a portion of his salary to facilitate a trade. Benintendi remains a seasoned veteran, boasting a solid OPS+ and power numbers, making him an enticing option in a market characterized by limited offensive production.