Introduction

The 2025 Major League Baseball offseason brought plenty of surprises, with top players like Corbin Burnes heading to the Diamondbacks and Luis Severino making a move to the Athletics. With free agency just around the corner again, analysts are predicting unlikely but plausible destinations for this year’s biggest names. Utilizing Joel Reuter's recent Big Board of the top 25 free agents, we delve into potential dark horse signings that could shake things up as teams look to invest in their futures.

Potential Dark Horse Signings

In the spirit of offseason speculation, let's take a look at some players along with their logical and dark horse landing spots. These teams are looking increasingly likely to shake up their rosters.

Ryan O'Hearn

Logical Landing Spot: San Diego PadresDark Horse: Milwaukee Brewers

With Rhys Hoskins likely departing, O'Hearn could add depth at first base for the Brewers.

Tyler Rogers

Logical Landing Spot: Los Angeles DodgersDark Horse: Athletics

Rogers’ unique delivery could be a valuable asset for the Athletics, particularly in a hitter-friendly environment.

Merrill Kelly

Logical Landing Spot: San Diego PadresDark Horse: Pittsburgh Pirates

The Pirates typically look for affordable veteran pitchers and Kelly fits that bill perfectly.

Harrison Bader

Logical Landing Spot: Philadelphia PhilliesDark Horse: Cleveland Guardians

Bader showcased his capabilities with the Phillies last season, and the Guardians should look to strengthen their outfield.

J.T. Realmuto

Logical Landing Spot: Philadelphia PhilliesDark Horse: Minnesota Twins

The Twins could enhance their catching situation significantly with Realmuto, forming a strong tandem with Ryan Jeffers.

Robert Suarez

Logical Landing Spot: Texas RangersDark Horse: Baltimore Orioles

The Orioles might want to invest in a more permanent solution in their closer position as Suarez remains a strong candidate.

Trent Grisham

Logical Landing Spot: Philadelphia PhilliesDark Horse: Kansas City Royals

The Royals certainly need help in the outfield, making Grisham a compelling target despite budgetary concerns.

Cody Bellinger

Logical Landing Spot: New York YankeesDark Horse: Arizona Diamondbacks

The Diamondbacks have been showing greater willingness to spend, potentially making them a dark horse for Bellinger.

Kyle Schwarber

Logical Landing Spot: Chicago CubsDark Horse: Miami Marlins

Schwarber's talent fits the Marlins' need for power, giving them a significant boost.

Louis Arraez

Logical Landing Spot: San Francisco GiantsDark Horse: Los Angeles Angels

Bringing in Arraez could help the Angels who ranked last in batting average last season.

Conclusion

As the offseason progresses, a flurry of surprising moves is anticipated across the MLB. While some franchises may stay true to their expected strategies, there’s always the potential for bold, unexpected decisions that could transform the landscape of the league.