The New York Knicks appeared poised to secure a victory in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals. However, a stunning turn of events unfolded at Madison Square Garden as the Indiana Pacers overcame a substantial 14-point deficit with just over two-and-a-half minutes remaining, ultimately forcing overtime and prevailing with a score of 138-135.

Following the loss, Knicks head coach Tom Thibodeau reflected on the significant challenge posed by the Pacers, stating, 'They can score the ball. Aaron Nesmith got loose. Tyrese Haliburton hit big shots. You just can never let your guard down against them. No lead is safe.' Nesmith displayed exceptional shooting prowess, reminiscent of Reggie Miller, as he connected on six three-pointers in the fourth quarter. Haliburton capped off a stellar performance by hitting a fadeaway jumper just as time expired, his foot barely on the three-point line, which sent the game into overtime. The Pacers showcased an impressive scoring spree of 20 points within the final two minutes and 39 seconds of regulation.

In the extra period, Andrew Nembhard emerged as a critical contributor for Indiana, scoring seven points and helping to maintain the lead. Throughout the contest, it became clear that players from the Pacers consistently stepped up when it mattered most. While the Knicks’ inability to close out the game was evident, it is also fair to credit the Pacers for intensifying the pressure at crucial junctures. Head coach Rick Carlisle noted the determination of his team, saying, 'It's a muscle—the more you exercise it, the stronger it gets,' emphasizing their resilience in overcoming significant deficits. As the series progresses, the momentum gained from such a remarkable comeback has the potential to impact both teams, particularly given the significance of home-court advantage in playoff matchups.