The Indiana Pacers demonstrated their resilience once again during Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals against the New York Knicks at Madison Square Garden. Despite facing a significant 116-102 deficit with under four minutes remaining in regulation, the Pacers orchestrated a stunning comeback, scoring 23 points compared to only nine from the Knicks to force overtime. This determined effort culminated in a narrow 138-135 victory for Indiana.

Although Tyrese Haliburton appeared to secure the win with a buzzer-beater three-pointer, his toe was found to be on the line, nullifying the shot. Nevertheless, the Pacers maintained their momentum in overtime, with crucial late baskets from Obi Toppin and Andrew Nembhard sealing the victory. The New York Knicks had opportunities to force double-overtime, but missed three-point attempts from Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns dampened their chances, allowing Indiana to emerge with a remarkable win.

Haliburton's performance was pivotal, as he contributed significantly with 31 points and 11 assists. His proactive play in overtime accentuated his role as a key figure, though it was Aaron Nesmith’s impressive shooting that bolstered the team's momentum. Nesmith finished with 30 points, hitting 8-of-9 from beyond the arc, with six of those successful attempts occurring in a critical five-minute stretch at the end of regulation. This display not only showcased Nesmith's shooting prowess but also set the stage for a historic victory for the Pacers, who have consistently shown their ability to overcome deficits throughout the playoffs. The Knicks, on the other hand, faced disappointment as they were unable to capitalize on standout performances from Brunson, who scored 43 points, and Towns, who added 35 points and 12 rebounds. Towns stepped up admirably during the fourth quarter when Brunson was in foul trouble, but the Pacers' explosive finish overshadowed New York’s efforts. The Pacers, having eliminated the Knicks in a previous playoff round, showed once again that they do not shy away from pressure-filled environments. With their fast-paced play leading them to an impressive first half, Indiana found themselves with opportunities to create runs throughout the game, ultimately taking the series lead heading into Game 2.