NFL Season 2025: A Retrospective Report Card

The 2025 NFL season has come to a close, leaving us with plenty to analyze. With 30 teams wrapping up their campaigns and the New England Patriots and Seattle Seahawks solidifying their reputations as successful squads, it’s time to reflect on this wild season. Our assessments focus on win-loss records, statistical rankings, and trends in team performance, while also considering injuries and the strength of schedules. Let's dive into the grades for each team, focusing primarily on their regular-season performances, with some influence from playoff outcomes.

Buffalo Bills: C

With a solid record of 12 wins, the Bills might seem deserving of a better grade, but the expectations run high for a team that has struggled to break through to a Super Bowl. Despite the attractive win-loss tally, their repeated playoff disappointments weigh heavily on their evaluation. Following the firing of their head coach and the increasing pressures surrounding quarterback Josh Allen, the team is grappling with a growing sense of underachievement.

Miami Dolphins: C-

The Dolphins entered the season with low expectations, largely due to injuries that hindered their progress. Their midseason four-game winning streak briefly revived hopes of a playoff run, but ultimately, the team finished with a subpar record. Given Tua Tagovailoa's inconsistency and the team's poor performance against tough opponents, this grade seems fitting.

New England Patriots: A+

Contrary to their critics, the Patriots thrived under coach Mike Vrabel, boasting a 14-3 record. With standout performances from quarterback Drake Maye and an impressively dominant defense, they charged towards the Super Bowl with confidence, setting aside any concerns about the strength of their schedule. Their impressive campaign is undeniable, although some caution is warranted before the big game.

New York Jets: D-

The Jets experienced another disappointing season, managing only three wins with a concerning -203 scoring margin. A midseason house cleaning suggests they are rebuilding; however, the missed opportunities at the quarterback position leave fans puzzled about the direction of the franchise. With an unproductive season on both sides of the ball, improvements will be critical for the Jets moving forward.

Baltimore Ravens: D+

Despite having expectations of contention, the Ravens faltered significantly, finishing at just 8-9. Quarterback Lamar Jackson’s injuries plagued their season, but this does not excuse their overall defensive struggles. As they face the close of the John Harbaugh era, questions arise about whether they can mend their performance before it’s too late.

Cincinnati Bengals: D

Joe Burrow's talent gives hope for the future, but the Bengals failed to create a contingency plan during his absences, leading to a disappointing finish. Their struggles were compounded by ongoing issues with the offensive line and an underwhelming defense. Acknowledging Burrow's skill is vital, but improvements in team infrastructure are crucial for redemption.

Cleveland Browns: C

The Browns navigated a turbulent quarterback situation and still managed five wins. A lack of clarity at the quarterback position and a coaching vacancy necessitates a reshaping of the roster, but it is possible to see potential in their defense, positioning them for a moderate recovery.

Pittsburgh Steelers: B

The surprisingly competitive Steelers took home the division title bolstered by an aging Aaron Rodgers but will need to reassess their long-term strategy following Mike Tomlin’s era. While they enjoyed success this season, it begs the question of whether they can maintain momentum in the seasons to come.

Teams on the Brink of Success and Failure

Several teams demonstrated glimpses of potential, such as the Houston Texans (B) and the Indianapolis Colts (C). The Texans found success albeit hitting a ceiling with quarterback C.J. Stroud, while the Colts exhibited frenzy with a strong start before faltering in the latter half of the season.

Coaching Changes and New Beginnings

Other franchises remain in flux, like the Tennessee Titans (C+), who are still nurturing young talent amid a dramatic coaching change, and the Denver Broncos (A-), who exuded competitive spirit but need more sustainable strategies moving forward.

Grading The Disappointment: F and Below

At the disappointingly low end of the scale, we find the Kansas City Chiefs (F) and the Las Vegas Raiders (F). For the Chiefs, the decline of star quarterback Patrick Mahomes raised concerns about team viability, while the Raiders failed to capitalize on their roster's potential, pointing to a looming crisis.

Conclusion: A Season of Reflection

As we look back on the NFL season of 2025, it's clear that while some franchises thrived, many are left searching for answers. With the playoffs providing a glimpse into the potential of future contenders, upcoming offseason decisions will be vital in redefining team trajectories ahead of the next season.