Introduction

The 2025 Winter Meetings hosted by Major League Baseball in Orlando have wrapped up, with a host of significant free agent signings taking place over just a few days. While the event was light on trades, some major decisions were made regarding the futures of several notable players. Here’s a comprehensive look at the key signings and the grades for each.

Key Free Agent Signings

RHP Mike Soroka signs one-year, $7.5M contract with the Arizona DiamondbacksGrade: B+

The Diamondbacks add Mike Soroka to their rotation, a move that addresses their need for inexpensive arms. Although he comes with an extensive injury history, Soroka's potential as a back-end starter makes this a decent signing.

LHP Steven Matz signs two-year, $15M contract with the Tampa Bay RaysGrade: B-

The Rays hope Matz can transition back to a starting pitcher, marking a crucial role as they navigate an uncertain pitching situation. His injury history poses risks, but if healthy, he could prove valuable.

DH Kyle Schwarber signs five-year, $150M contract with the Philadelphia PhilliesGrade: B+

Schwarber remains with the Phillies, extending his tenure amidst interest from multiple teams. This hefty investment reflects the club's commitment to retaining talent, although questions remain about their overall roster completeness.

RHP Edwin Díaz signs three-year, $69M contract with the Los Angeles DodgersGrade: A

Díaz's contract sets a new standard for relievers, as he shifts from the Mets to the Dodgers. This strategic move addresses a significant need for the Dodgers, marking a major offseason win.

LHP Gregory Soto signs one-year, $7.75M contract with the Pittsburgh PiratesGrade: B-

The Pirates fill a gap in their bullpen with Soto, but this signing aligns with a history of underwhelming moves, prompting concerns about their approach this winter.

RHP Kyle Finnegan signs two-year, $19M contract with the Detroit TigersGrade: D+

This commitment comes after a less-than-stellar history, leading to skepticism around the long-term value of this investment, particularly as the market for relievers heats up.

1B Pete Alonso signs five-year, $155M contract with the Baltimore OriolesGrade: A

The Orioles' aggressive pursuit of Alonso signals a shift in their spending strategy as they sign a first baseman to a major deal, a historical first for the club in terms of recent free-agent contracts.

OF Mike Yastrzemski signs two-year, $23M contract with the Atlanta BravesGrade: B+

Yastrzemski’s addition enhances the Braves' outfield depth, and at a reasonable price, he offers experience and versatility, vital assets in a season marked by injuries.

Conclusion

While the 2025 Winter Meetings yielded fewer transactions than in past years, the quality of signings is evident with several impactful agreements. As teams finalize their rosters and prepare for the upcoming season, these moves will undoubtedly shape the competitive landscape of Major League Baseball.