2019 MLB Draft Overview
The 2019 MLB Draft is known for its rich talent pool, which featured standout players such as Adley Rutschman, Bobby Witt Jr., and Corbin Carroll. Rutschman, a catcher from Oregon State, was a consensus No. 1 overall pick, coming off an impressive collegiate season where he boasted a .411 batting average accompanied by 17 home runs. Though the Baltimore Orioles took Rutschman first overall, the event has led fans and analysts to speculate how different MLB team rosters might look in a hypothetical redraft.
Redraft Mechanics and Assessments
In this speculative reimagining of the draft, each MLB team's current roster remains unchanged, with only the first-round picks subject to revision. This framework allows for deeper consideration of organizational fit and roster mechanics—a critical factor in evaluating the best talent for each team’s needs.
Baltimore Orioles: Bobby Witt Jr. at No. 1
Initially selecting Adley Rutschman, the Baltimore Orioles may choose to pivot to Bobby Witt Jr. in this redraft. While Rutschman started his career strong with a 5.4 WAR rookie season, his performance has plateaued over subsequent years. Witt Jr., originally drafted second overall by the Kansas City Royals, has quickly become one of the premier shortstops in the league, leading all players in WAR for that position since 2022. Opting for Witt Jr., regarded as a bona fide superstar, enhances the Orioles' prospects even if it means slightly shifting organizational dynamics.
Kansas City Royals: Gunnar Henderson at No. 2
After losing Witt, the Royals would naturally turn to Gunnar Henderson as a replacement. Henderson, who was originally selected 42nd overall, has excelled as one of baseball's emerging stars, securing a respectable 21.6 WAR since entering the league. His immediate transition into the Royals roster serves as a seamless fit, providing organizational depth and a strong presence in their infield.
Chicago White Sox: Corbin Carroll at No. 3
In a parallel universe, the Chicago White Sox missed an opportunity when they selected Andrew Vaughn with the third pick. Corbin Carroll, originally chosen 16th overall by the Arizona Diamondbacks, has emerged as a critical asset for any roster. With two seasons logging 5 WAR and the potential for a 30/30 campaign, Carroll could provide the White Sox with the explosive outfield presence they desired from Vaughn, who has struggled defensively and offensively in recent years.
Miami Marlins: Michael Harris II at No. 4
After struggling in the outfield film, the Marlins pivot towards Michael Harris II instead of their original pick JJ Bleday. Harris has tallied a solid 16.1 WAR throughout his tenure in the league, earning accolades as 2022's NL Rookie of the Year and confirming his potential as an impactful contributor going forward. His development presents an opportunity the Marlins have sought since the departures of their former stars.
Detroit Tigers: CJ Abrams at No. 5
In reflecting on past choices, the Tigers might reconsider their selection of Riley Greene in favor of CJ Abrams. Since being drafted sixth overall, Abrams has shown significant promise, establishing himself as a power-speed threat. Additionally, his fit at the shortstop position could address an existing need for the Tigers, offering solid production while bolstering the infield depth.
San Diego Padres: Adley Rutschman at No. 6
With Rutschman’s availability in this reimagined draft, the Padres can finally address a pressing need—catcher. Despite his recent performance dip, Rutschman's pedigree is undeniable, and his selection could mark a turning point for the Padres, who have struggled to find consistency behind the plate.
Cincinnati Reds: Riley Greene at No. 7
The Reds would undoubtedly benefit from re-drafting Riley Greene, who had great potential. While they originally picked Nick Lodolo, Greene provides a clear upgrade in the outfield, especially as the organization has struggled to develop homegrown talent in recent years.
Conclusion: Sifting Through Talent
This hypothetical redraft allows teams to reevaluate their selections and consider the evolving dynamics within their rosters. The 2019 draft class is filled with talent that continues to impact their respective franchises significantly. As time progresses, teams may glean insights into what players to prioritize based on the fit, performance, and long-term vision. The exercise illustrates not only the shifting fortunes of players but also how unpredictable and consequential the draft process can be.
