The New York Knicks find themselves on the brink of elimination in the Eastern Conference Finals, trailing 3-1 after a 130-121 defeat to the Indiana Pacers. Following successful six-game series wins in the first two rounds, the Knicks now face a significant challenge as they return to Madison Square Garden for Game 5.

While the odds of winning three consecutive games, especially two on home court, appear daunting, it prompts an examination of the factors leading to this 3-1 deficit. One player whose performance has come under scrutiny is Jalen Brunson, the superstar point guard who was recently named Clutch Player of the Year. Despite averaging 29.9 points in the playoffs, Brunson's individual rating has revealed a concerning narrative. Over the course of the series, the Knicks have a cumulative deficit of 11 points, while Brunson's own plus-minus stands at minus-26. Effectively, the team has performed better during non-Brunson minutes, raising questions about his impact on team dynamics and offensive rhythm. His tendency to dominate the ball can disrupt the flow of play, making it difficult for teammates to stay engaged. Furthermore, Brunson's height disadvantage against a physically imposing Pacers team makes him a vulnerable target defensively.

In contrast, role players Mikal Bridges and OG Anunoby, while not underperforming—Bridges averages 17.0 points and shoots 40.0 percent from beyond the arc, while Anunoby is at 17.5 points—have not significantly contributed in other statistical categories, such as rebounds and assists. Both players were acquired under circumstances that suggest higher expectations, particularly given the substantial assets the Knicks invested in Bridges. The performance of this forward duo, combining for just 8.0 rebounds, 4.0 assists, and 3.8 turnovers in the conference finals, has been disappointing. While Brunson's style may inhibit their contributions, both players are capable of influencing games more assertively. Additionally, Aaron Nesmith's presence for the Pacers has been impactful, as he contributed a team-high plus-20 in Game 4, and his ability to defend Brunson has notably hampered the Knicks offense. As New York grapples with its current predicament, the depth of the Pacers, showcased through players like Tyrese Haliburton, is a critical factor. Haliburton has emerged as a postseason star, delivering historic performances, including a triple-double with 32 points, 15 assists, and 12 rebounds in Game 4. His consistent output in the playoffs is a significant aspect of the Pacers' success, leaving the Knicks in a challenging position as they aim to combat the escalating talents of their opponents.