Introduction

As the NFL season enters Week 4 in 2025, fantasy managers face the challenge of navigating tough matchups amidst a wave of player injuries. Stars like Joe Burrow, George Kittle, and James Conner may be sidelined, affecting the performance of their teammates, including Ja'Marr Chase. With this backdrop, we present critical start/sit recommendations based on point-per-reception (PPR) scoring for some of the most challenging matchups this week.

Quinshon Judkins Should Shine Against Lions

The Cleveland Browns shocked fans with a comeback victory over the Green Bay Packers in Week 3, but their upcoming challenge against the Detroit Lions promises to be significantly tougher. The Lions' defense has allowed the ninth-fewest fantasy points to opposing running backs, yet rookie Quinshon Judkins has emerged as a focal point of Cleveland's offense. After a notable performance of 95 scrimmage yards and a touchdown against the Packers, Judkins is expected to deliver another solid stat line this week against Detroit.

Jacory Croskey-Merritt: A Risky Play

In Washington, running back Jacory Croskey-Merritt has exceeded expectations for a seventh-round pick, finding the end zone in two of his first three games. However, the heavy backfield rotation complicates his fantasy reliability. With the Commanders facing an Atlanta Falcons defense that allows the sixth-fewest fantasy points to running backs, Croskey-Merritt may be a poor choice this week. Instead, fantasy managers should consider other options for their lineup.

Deebo Samuel's Role Remains Strong

While the Falcons have limited production against opposing receivers, Deebo Samuel's dual-threat capabilities keep him in the conversation. With Terry McLaurin's injury impacting the command of targets in Washington's receiving game, Samuel's role is expected to grow. Despite not exceeding 50 scrimmage yards since Week 1, Samuel's target share has remained impressive, making him a viable choice for Week 4.

Ja'Marr Chase vs. Tee Higgins: Contrasting Prospects

Cincinnati Bengals superstar Ja'Marr Chase presents a conundrum this week due to quarterback Jake Browning stepping in for the injured Joe Burrow. While Chase possesses high upside, Tee Higgins' value is clouded by Burrow's absence. Despite a decent outing against the Jaguars in Week 3, Higgins has struggled in other games, making him a matchup-dependent player at best. With the Bengals set to take on the Denver Broncos, Higgins's chances for success appear dim against a defense that allows few points to receivers.

Conclusion

As fantasy football managers prepare for Week 4, it’s crucial to assess matchups carefully. With injuries and performance variability among key players, making informed start/sit decisions could be the difference between victory and defeat.