Introduction

As the 2025 NFL season approaches its final weeks, it's an opportune moment to assess the head-coaching hires from this offseason. Many teams might already be reflecting on their decisions as they monitor progress on the field. In this evaluation, we will grade all seven coaching hires based on their team's performance, player development, and playoff prospects.

Pete Carroll - Las Vegas Raiders (Record: 2-12) - Grade: F

Pete Carroll, known for his ability to build winning cultures, has faced significant challenges with the Raiders. Underestimating the team's rebuilding needs and making questionable staffing decisions, Carroll's tenure has led to a fractured coaching staff. His criticisms of offensive coordinator Chip Kelly and struggles with a poor offensive line have compounded the team's issues, resulting in a disastrous record that has many questioning his future.

Liam Coen - Jacksonville Jaguars (Record: 10-4) - Grade: A

In stark contrast, Liam Coen has revitalized the Jaguars, leading them to a potential playoff berth with a top-10 scoring offense and defense. His ability to learn from mistakes and foster accountability has positively impacted the locker room, and the Jaguars are on the right track, posing a threat to playoff-caliber teams.

Aaron Glenn - New York Jets (Record: 3-11) - Grade: D

Aaron Glenn's early season struggles have included benching quarterback Justin Fields after a rocky start. Despite the Jets' poor record, the team showed resilience, achieving surprising victories amidst key injuries. While Glenn has work to do, glimpses of competitiveness in the team hint at potential improvement with a more robust roster.

Ben Johnson - Chicago Bears (Record: 10-4) - Grade: A-

Ben Johnson has transformed the Bears' offense, leading it to its highest production in a decade. His guidance over quarterback Caleb Williams has yielded strong performances, making the Bears a formidable team as they head into the closing games of the season, still vying for the playoffs.

Kellen Moore - New Orleans Saints (Record: 4-10) - Grade: C

After a shaky start, Kellen Moore appears to be steering the Saints toward improvement. With rookie quarterback Tyler Shough showing promise, paired with a defense that has improved significantly, Moore is gradually making strides in what is seen as a rebuilding season for New Orleans.

Brian Schottenheimer - Dallas Cowboys (Record: 6-7-1) - Grade: B-

Though initially criticized, Brian Schottenheimer's offensive strategies have sparked productivity within Dallas, making the Cowboys a high-scoring team. However, defense remains a concern, and the team has struggled to maintain consistency in performance.

Mike Vrabel - New England Patriots (Record: 11-3) - Grade: A

Finally, Mike Vrabel has exceeded expectations in his first season with the Patriots. His leadership has brought a newfound vigor, propelling them to the top of the AFC East. With a young quarterback flourishing under his system and an impressive defense, the Patriots are poised for a playoff run.

Conclusion

As the season winds down, these head coaches exhibit a range of outcomes from promising beginnings to troubling situations. The evaluations suggest that while some teams are on the rise, others may need to reconsider their leadership approaches in the near future.