Evaluating the Best NHL Players Over the Last 25 Years
One of the most enjoyable initiatives taken by the NHL this year was the announcement of each franchise's quarter-century team. A panel of voters in each city was tasked with selecting players they felt deserved recognition, leading to an interesting reflection on who made the cut for each team. This exercise not only allowed a retrospective look at the franchises but also fostered discussions about individual player contributions over the past 25 years.
In considering the best representation for the Anaheim Ducks, Ryan Getzlaf stands out as the face of the franchise for a significant portion of that time. Since commencing his NHL career in 2005, Getzlaf amassed 1,157 games and 1,019 points, serving as captain from 2010 until his retirement in 2022, and playing a crucial role in their Stanley Cup victory in 2007. The discussion also brings Teemu Selänne into the spotlight, particularly for his impactful tenure in the late 90s and again post-lockout; however, a focus on contributions over the last 25 years solidifies Getzlaf's position as the standout player during that span.
For the Boston Bruins, the debate centers around Patrice Bergeron and Zdeno Chára, two unabashed icons of the franchise. Bergeron emerges as the choice due to his six Selke Trophy wins and vital contributions during their 2011 Stanley Cup championship. Having joined the Bruins in 2003, Bergeron registered 1,040 points across 1,294 games, while Chára's transformative presence elevated the Bruins to perennial playoff contenders, stemming from his arrival from Ottawa. Despite Chára's significant impact, the cumulative acumen shown by Bergeron on the ice, particularly in two-way play and consistent performance solely for the Bruins, leads to his selection as the best player over this timeframe.
The Buffalo Sabres have had a tumultuous journey over the past 25 years, with goaltending remaining a defining element of the franchise. Ryan Miller became the face of the Sabres, carrying on the legacy of Dominik Hašek after his departure in 2001. Miller notched an impressive 284 wins and 28 shutouts during his tenure, guiding the Sabres to the Eastern Conference Finals in both 2006 and 2007. Furthermore, his accolades include winning the Vezina Trophy in 2010, showcasing his elite status. Despite his trade to St. Louis in 2014, Miller remains the most recent goalie to achieve playoff success with the Sabres, marking him as a significant figure in the team's history.
In Calgary, few players have embodied the spirit of the franchise like Jarome Iginla. From 1996 until his trade in 2013, Iginla compiled 899 points across 908 games, earning accolades such as multiple Rocket Richard Trophies and leading the Flames to the Stanley Cup Final in 2004. His legacy transcends statistics; Iginla was revered for his competitive spirit and connection to the community. The date of his departure from the Flames remains a somber moment for fans, given his indelible impact on the franchise.
The Carolina Hurricanes have seen several players rise to prominence, notably Eric Staal, Sebastian Aho, and Cam Ward. However, Rod Brind'Amour, the captain of their 2006 Stanley Cup team and current head coach, captures the essence of success during this timeframe. His leadership facilitated the franchise's inaugural championship, and since taking on the coaching role, he has consistently led the team to playoff appearances, solidifying his stature in the team’s history.
For the Chicago Blackhawks, the pre-2008 landscape was marked by struggles until the drafting of Jonathan Toews and Patrick Kane reignited the franchise. Kane, in particular, quickly distinguished himself as a top offensive talent, garnering 1,225 points in 1,161 games and playing a crucial role in three Stanley Cup victories. His dynamic scoring and playmaking abilities established him as an all-time great for the franchise, underscoring the significance of this talent acquisition in shaping the Blackhawks' destiny.
Joe Sakic's enduring legacy with the Colorado Avalanche places him firmly in discussions of the franchise's top player over the last 25 years. As a player, Sakic contributed 581 points in 526 games during this period, helping secure the Stanley Cup in both 1996 and 2001. His transition to a team executive paved the way for the Avalanche to shape their future, with pivotal drafts resulting in stars such as Gabriel Landeskog and Nathan MacKinnon. Sakic's footprint on both the ice and in executive decision-making frames him as a defining figure of the franchise.
The Columbus Blue Jackets have their history etched since their inception in the 2000-2001 season, and Rick Nash remains their standout player. As the first overall pick in the 2003 draft, Nash established franchise records for goals (289) and points (574) during his time there. Despite challenges faced by the franchise, Nash's prominence as a premier player carved a clear identity for the Blue Jackets in their formative years.
In Dallas, the debate over the best player in the last 25 years is intensely contested among figures like Mike Modano, Jamie Benn, and Brenden Morrow. Ultimately, however, Mike Modano claims the top spot as he was the face of the franchise through their transition from Minnesota to Dallas. In his later years, he maintained elite scoring with 543 points in games played from 2000-2010, while his legacy as a hockey ambassador for the region remains unparalleled.
When assessing the Detroit Red Wings, Nicklas Lidström emerges as the unequivocal choice for best player over the last 25 years. His tenure included seven Norris Trophy wins, which underscored his dominance as a defenseman. Lidström's contributions were integral to the Red Wings' success, leading them to Stanley Cup championships in 2002 and 2008 while earning the Conn Smythe Trophy in 2002. His high-level performance and leadership qualities mark him as a legend in the franchise's storied history.
In Edmonton, the arrival of Connor McDavid served as a transformative moment for the franchise. Winning the draft lottery in 2015 allowed the Oilers to select McDavid, who has since become a perennial scoring leader and MVP. With over 1,000 points in his first 688 games, McDavid's mix of skill and speed has elevated the Oilers into playoff contention and rekindled excitement within the fan base, establishing him as a critical figure for the franchise’s future.
The Florida Panthers saw a remarkable season culminate in their first Stanley Cup victory, largely powered by the efforts of Aleksander Barkov. As the franchise's top scorer since 2000-2001, his overall influence as a two-way player has been substantial. While Roberto Luongo’s contributions as a goalie cannot be overlooked, led by his incredible save percentage and shutouts, Barkov's recent success as captain highlights his role in shaping the team's identity.
Anže Kopitar’s legacy with the Los Angeles Kings places him as one of their greatest players and complements his role as a dual-threat player. Over a committed career with the Kings, he crafted a name for himself as a top scorer and elite two-way forward. Kopitar’s contributions were crucial in their two Stanley Cup victories and his scoring records underscore his significance to the franchise.
For the Minnesota Wild, Mikko Koivu’s reign represents the quintessential history of the franchise. Koivu, the first player to captain the Wild through multiple seasons, chose his leadership to define the team's identity over 16 seasons. His status as the franchise's all-time leading scorer is a testament to his enduring impact and commitment to the organization.
With a legacy as one of the greatest goaltenders in NHL history, Carey Price stands prominently among the Montréal Canadiens' all-time greats. His playoff performances, leading the team to the Stanley Cup Final in 2021, showcased his ability to elevate the team's success in high-stakes situations. Price's accolades, including the Vezina, Hart, and Lindsay awards, further verify his stature as one of the best to ever wear the Canadiens jersey.
Pekka Rinne claims the title of the best player for the Nashville Predators over the past 25 years. His remarkable achievements include a Vezina Trophy win and leading the Predators to a Stanley Cup Final appearance. Rinne became a symbol of stability for the franchise, not only in terms of his goaltending prowess but also for his influential role in the community and the growth of hockey in Nashville.
Martin Brodeur is synonymous with the New Jersey Devils, and his storied career with the franchise highlights his unmatched achievements. Brodeur's combined playoff and regular season successes, including four Vezina Trophies and three Stanley Cups, solidified his place as the greatest player in franchise history. His longevity and excellence have made him a lasting figure in the league’s goaltending fraternity.
John Tavares remains a vital figure in the narrative of the New York Islanders, having cemented his legacy with the franchise through impressive point totals and leadership. While he helped the team reach playoff contention, his departure for Toronto sparked intense emotions among fans. Tavares’s contributions during his tenure compel recognition as the Islanders' best player over the last quarter-century.
Henrik Lundqvist established himself as the transcendent star of the New York Rangers. A constant in goal from 2005 to 2020, Lundqvist's Vezina win and consistent presence provided the Rangers a foundation for their success during his era. His durability and statistics underscore the significance he holds among the franchise's elite players.
Daniel Alfredsson captured the heart of the Ottawa Senators throughout his career with the organization. Serving as captain, his leadership extended to an impressive post-season run in 2007, guiding the Senators to the Stanley Cup Final. Despite a rocky departure from the team, Alfredsson’s ongoing influence within the organization makes him a cherished figure in the franchise's history.
Claude Giroux’s impact on the Philadelphia Flyers has been palpable since his arrival in 2008. With a prolific scoring record, he excelled as a two-way forward and led the Flyers to a Stanley Cup Final appearance in 2010. Despite facing adversity during his tenure, Giroux remains beloved among Philadelphia fans, marking him as the franchise's top player of the last 25 years.
Sidney Crosby is unequivocally the best player for the Pittsburgh Penguins, boasting accomplishments that are among the pinnacle in hockey history. Since his debut, he's led the team to three Stanley Cups, winning multiple individual trophies, including the Hart and Art Ross Trophies. Crosby’s stellar career continues to captivate, and his legacy is profound as one of the NHL's all-time greats.
Joe Thornton's remarkable tenure with the San Jose Sharks established him as one of the franchise's finest players. Since his trade from Boston in 2005, he amassed 1,055 points while propelling players around him to new heights. His presence was foundational in leading the Sharks to the Stanley Cup Final in 2016, and recent retirements and honors further solidify his legacy within the organization and the sport.
As a nascent franchise, the Seattle Kraken saw Jared McCann rise as their foremost player since inception. Notably, his scoring prowess positions him as a key player in the team's early years, leading the franchise in points within a short timeframe. While other emerging talents like Matty Beniers are also notable, McCann’s lift in performance outlines his importance to Seattle's identity.
The St. Louis Blues faced an interesting juxtaposition in selecting their best player, with an array of talent such as Alexander Steen and David Backes. Ultimately, Vladimir Tarasenko stood out due to his goal-scoring capability, consistently being the go-to player for clutch moments and helping the Blues secure their first Stanley Cup in 2019 despite later challenges within the franchise.
Steven Stamkos has shaped the history of the Tampa Bay Lightning since being drafted first overall in 2008. His prolific scoring has translated into multiple accolades, including leading the team to consecutive Stanley Cup championships in 2020 and 2021. Stamkos's recent departure from the franchise marks the end of an era but highlights a legacy that firmly establishes him as one of the best to wear the Lightning jersey.
In Toronto, Auston Matthews has emerged as a central figure in the Maple Leafs' recent resurgence and success. His goal-scoring ability eclipses his peers, making a case for him as the best player in the franchise’s recent history. As a key contributor in pivotal moments, Matthews continues to establish himself as a potential franchise cornerstone for years to come.
Examining the legacy of franchise players in the modern NHL provides a glimpse into how individual contributions shape team identity and success. The ongoing evolution of the league prompts continued reflections that honor these players while inspiring future generations in the world of professional hockey.