Dallas Stars Face Tough Decisions After Playoff Exit

In recent days, the Dallas Stars have faced a challenging period following their elimination from the Western Conference Final for the third consecutive year. This time, they were ousted by the Edmonton Oilers in a five-game series, the same team that defeated them last season. The situation became more scrutinized when goaltender Jake Oettinger was pulled early in the final game, raising questions about head coach Pete DeBoer's decision-making. These incidents have prompted discussions regarding potential roster changes, particularly the viability of trading superstar winger Jason Robertson, as suggested by Jeff Marek in a recent blog at Daily Faceoff.
With Robertson heading into the final year of his contract next season, discussions surrounding his future with the team are particularly relevant. His current cap hit of $7.75 million is viewed as manageable; however, the Stars will be navigating salary cap constraints next season, especially with $90.5 million already committed as the cap rises to $95.5 million. The Stars must evaluate their roster and consider adjustments necessary to advance further in the playoffs. Several teams have emerged as possible trade partners for Robertson, who possesses a skill set that would enhance any lineup.
One potential destination for Robertson is the Anaheim Ducks, who would accommodate his cap hit while also holding enough space to negotiate an extension beyond the upcoming season. The Ducks have shown promise with their young talent, including Troy Terry, Trevor Zegras, and Leo Carlsson, and adding an experienced player like Robertson could significantly bolster their forward group. Additionally, Anaheim has depth on defense, making it a feasible partner for a trade that could address Dallas's needs on the blue line.
The Ottawa Senators have also been mentioned as a potential suitor for Robertson, although they may face challenges in making the trade due to their limited defensive depth and a lack of draft picks. However, adding a player of Robertson's caliber would greatly enhance their forward lineup alongside Brady Tkachuk, Tim Stützle, and Dylan Cozens. For the Senators, acquiring Robertson could solidify their position in the competitive Atlantic Division as they aim to maintain postseason contention.
Conversely, trading within their division raises the stakes for the Stars. The Calgary Flames may express interest in acquiring Robertson, as doing so would provide them with an elite forward to complement their offensive core, which includes Jonathan Huberdeau and Nazem Kadri. The Flames possess defensemen such as MacKenzie Weegar or Rasmus Andersson, who could facilitate a trade, allowing Dallas to strengthen their blue line significantly while also gaining financial relief under the salary cap.
The Buffalo Sabres, known for their wealth of prospects and draft picks, could also emerge as a prime candidate for a trade involving Robertson. With significant questions surrounding some of their current roster players, the Sabres possess restricted free agents like JJ Peterka and defenseman Bo Byram who could be leveraged in a major deal. Securing Robertson would provide the Sabres with a dynamic forward to reinvigorate their offense, helping end their playoff drought. Should the Stars acquire Byram, it would enhance their defensive corps with a young player poised for continued development.
In Toronto, the Maple Leafs face a dilemma as forward Mitch Marner approaches free agency, leaving them with a critical gap to fill if he does not re-sign. Acquiring Robertson could provide a strategic solution to this issue, provided they manage their existing contracts effectively. However, the Leafs' lack of top prospects and a first-round pick in the coming seasons complicate trade negotiations.
The New York Islanders, under their new general manager Mathieu Darche, may also benefit from adding Robertson, considering their historical struggles with offensive depth. Trading restricted free agent defenseman Noah Dobson could open the door for a deal that not only enhances the team offensively but also addresses future scoring needs. The combination of Robertson with Mathew Barzal and Bo Horvat would significantly increase the Islanders' offensive capabilities, drawing a clear contrast to their recent performance.
Lastly, the Detroit Red Wings find themselves in a critical juncture as they attempt to break a nine-year playoff drought. General manager Steve Yzerman's moves in pursuit of improvement have shown promise, yet trading for a player of Robertson's caliber could represent a bold statement regarding their competitiveness. The Red Wings possess young talent and prospects, and the addition of Robertson alongside established forwards like Dylan Larkin and Alex DeBrincat would make a notable impact in their drive for postseason success.
Another noteworthy option for the Hurricanes revolves around their pursuit of an elite scoring winger. Their recent attempts to bolster their forward group demonstrate a clear interest in such additions. Trading for Robertson could present an opportunity to both resolve immediate scoring needs and establish a long-term presence on the roster. Given their established trading relationship with the Stars, Carolina may find this to be a mutually beneficial scenario.








