College Baseball Season Sets the Stage for MLB Draft Prospects

As the college baseball season approaches its conclusion, anticipation for the MLB draft intensifies. Although the official draft will not take place until mid-July, several top prospects are preparing for significant showcases during their respective conference tournaments. Excelling in these games could significantly enhance their standings on draft boards as scouts assess their performances under pressure.
One of the most anticipated analyses comes from expert mock drafts that outline the potential first selections. Notably, McDaniel's updated top-150 prospect rankings accompany a mini-mock draft projecting the initial 14 picks. The list prominently features high school players, with four out of the first seven selections hailing from prep schools. McDaniel begins with Ethan Holliday, a third baseman from Stillwater High School in Oklahoma, renowned as the son of seven-time All-Star Matt Holliday and brother of Baltimore Orioles infielder Jackson Holliday. However, McDaniel advises caution, noting that the draft landscape remains fluid. Following Holliday, Florida State's left-handed pitcher Jamie Arnold is expected to be selected, along with Corona High School's right-hander Seth Hernandez.
Further down the lineup, college left-handers Tennessee's Liam Doyle and LSU's Kade Anderson are forecasted to be picked, followed by shortstops Billy Carlson from Hernandez's school and Eli Willits from Fort Cobb-Broxton High School in Oklahoma. The list continues with Oregon State's Aiva Arquette, a shortstop, and Texas A&M's centerfielder Jace LaViolette, before concluding with Oklahoma's right-handed pitcher Kyson Witherspoon and prep shortstop JoJo Parker from Purvis High School in Mississippi. Meanwhile, Mayo's comprehensive mock draft covers 27 prospects, highlighting a mix of college pitchers and high school middle infielders at the forefront.
Comparisons between McDaniel's and Mayo's projections reveal a striking similarity, as the first eleven players overlap despite minor positional variations. Mayo also kicks off with Holliday and Arnold, placing Doyle at No. 3 and Arquette at No. 4. Notably, Mayo suggests the Colorado Rockies could opt for a collegiate pitcher with their fourth pick, but if a college hitter is preferred, Arquette—boasting 17 home runs and an OPS above 1.100—stands out as the choice. In a twist, Anderson finds himself at No. 6 under Mayo's analysis, reflecting the historical hesitations teams have regarding right-handed prep pitchers. Mayo emphasizes Anderson's ranking as one of the preeminent high school athletes, trailing only Holliday in the rankings.
Reuter's mock draft presents a distinct view as it bypasses Holliday for the top pick, instead selecting Arnold for his compelling combination of potential, stability, and readiness for the majors. Holliday does not appear in the second or third spots, which are filled by Arquette and Hernandez, respectively. Reuter credits Arquette for his impressive performance during the junior season, which has elevated his status due to better walk and strikeout rates and a shift from second base to shortstop. In assessing Hernandez, Reuter highlights the attributes that could establish him as the next elite pitching prospect.
Holliday slides to the No. 4 position as the Rockies are expected to draft him, with Reuter labeling him as a 'potential offensive superstar' and comparing his style more closely to his power-hitting father than to his more contact-focused brother. A noteworthy addition at No. 5 is Wake Forest's shortstop Marek Houston, previously ranked No. 15 by Mayo. Reuter notes that Houston's well-rounded game and high floor position him as a strong candidate for selection in the top ten. The final mention in the top ten by Reuter includes UC Santa Barbara's righty Tyler Bremner, who has seen fluctuations in ranking due to inconsistent starts but is trending upward. Reuter speculates that Bremner could be a potential pick for the Chicago White Sox as they navigate the early stages of a rebuilding phase.








