The Toronto Blue Jays are unlikely to engage in trade discussions involving first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr., although interest has reportedly emerged. The New York Mets have reached out to the Blue Jays regarding Guerrero, as reported by Andy Martino from SNY. However, this inquiry was characterized as a mere check-in rather than a substantial trade proposal. Notably, this development coincides with the Mets pressuring Pete Alonso to make a timely decision regarding his free-agent destination, leading to speculation that the team may explore alternative options for first base if Alonso signs elsewhere.

Guerrero's overall performance in the past few seasons has generated conversation around his potential availability. After an off year in 2023, he rebounded in 2024, achieving a .940 OPS and hitting 30 home runs, his third season with at least 30 homers in four years. Despite this resurgence, the Blue Jays are coming off a disappointing last-place finish in the American League East, leaving the future of many key players, including Guerrero, uncertain. His upcoming salary of $28.5 million in what will be his final year before free agency adds complexity to the situation. The Blue Jays' interest in acquiring Pete Alonso adds another layer, with reports suggesting a vision of Guerrero and Alonso playing together if the acquisition occurs.

The idea of trading Guerrero becomes more plausible if several factors align: missing out on Alonso, failing to acquire Rōki Sasaki, and the deadline for Guerrero's extension passing without a deal. Baseball Trade Values estimates Guerrero's surplus value—considering his impending salary—at $21.2 million, positioning him as a valuable asset for any team. Several teams may emerge as potential trade partners, and while this speculation remains hypothetical, it is worth examining various destinations and trade packages that could arise in such a scenario.