Introduction

As the 2025 MLB season wraps up, Cal Raleigh and Kyle Schwarber emerged as strong candidates for MVP, identified as significant players even when the betting odds favored Aaron Judge and Shohei Ohtani. With Raleigh smashing 60 home runs while catching, both players put forth outstanding seasons. But as we look ahead, who might take an unexpected leap in the 2026 campaign? Here’s a look at some potential MVP contenders who could rise to the occasion.

Michael Harris II

Though Michael Harris II struggled out of the gate in 2025 with a .234 batting average and a .510 OPS, his post-All-Star Break resurgence—batting .299 with 14 home runs—might hint that he still has MVP potential. The former NL Rookie of the Year finished the season with a career-high 20 home runs, and his elite defensive skills, including 26 defensive runs saved, underline his overall value to a struggling Braves team.

Wyatt Langford

Joining the list is Wyatt Langford from the Texas Rangers, who showed promise in his age-23 season. Hitting 22 home runs and boasting a .775 OPS, he emerged as a notable offensive player on a team that underperformed. As he continues to excel defensively with 16 defensive runs saved, a breakout year could position him as a future AL MVP candidate once established stars like Judge transition out of their peak.

Will Smith

Will Smith, fresh off a pivotal role in the World Series, could surprise many if he scales new heights in 2026. Despite competing against stars like Shohei Ohtani and Mookie Betts on the Dodgers, Smith's strong .296 batting average and .901 OPS in 2025 suggest he may have more to offer. If he challenges for MVP alongside his teammates, the Dodgers could achieve a historic season.

Adley Rutschman

Adley Rutschman’s inclusion highlights a critical moment in his career. Despite a dismal 2025 campaign where he hit just .220, his past accolades signal that he still has the potential to become a star. As he approaches 28, Rutschman's well-rounded skills, previously recognized with an All-Star selection and Silver Slugger Award, could lead to a resurgence worthy of MVP consideration.

Daniel Soderstrom

Daniel Soderstrom stands out in the Athletics’ lineup, showcasing a remarkable first full MLB season with 25 home runs and an .820 OPS. His successful defensive transition to left field, achieving 10 defensive runs saved, adds another dimension to his value. A breakout offensive season could place him firmly in MVP discussions as the Athletics strive for postseason success.

Wilyer Abreu

Wilyer Abreu, who recently secured his second consecutive Gold Glove with notable defensive metrics, rounds out this list. With 22 home runs and a .786 OPS, he represents a blend of outstanding defensive prowess and solid offensive contributions. If he can elevate his performance further, Abreu has the tools to be an MVP candidate among the Red Sox's young talent.

Conclusion

As we step into the 2026 MLB season, these players each have the potential to defy expectations and break into the MVP conversation. Whether through offensive surges or elite defensive contributions, it’s clear the competition for the league's most valuable player is wide open.