Introduction

A year ago, two prominent MLB players, Jacob deGrom and George Springer, found themselves on Bleacher Report's list of the worst contracts for their respective teams. Fast forward to today, both players have not only silenced critics but also made significant contributions to their teams in the past season. DeGrom, in particular, was an All-Star in his age-37 season, posting an impressive 2.97 ERA and finishing in the top-10 for the Cy Young Awards for the first time since 2021. Meanwhile, Springer turned his season around, winning a Silver Slugger award and helping lead the Toronto Blue Jays to an AL pennant. This raises an intriguing question: Who will be the 2026 players looking for a redemption arc similar to deGrom and Springer?

Players on the Chopping Block

Every year, Major League Baseball features contracts that, at some points, seem burdensome. As teams begin their preparations for the upcoming season, it’s important to take stock of players who are underperforming relative to their contracts. Here's a look at several players across the league who are in a similar position as they enter 2026.

1. Toronto Blue Jays: Andrés Giménez

Original Contract: Seven years, $106.5 million with a $23 million club option for 2030Remaining Money: $86.3 million through 2030After an impressive defensive year, Andrés Giménez is set to take over at shortstop for the Toronto Blue Jays, especially after Bo Bichette's departure to the New York Mets. While he has shown defensive excellence, with three Gold Glove Awards to his name, the drop in offensive performance, evidenced by a .657 OPS since his outstanding .837 OPS season in 2022, raises concerns. He will need to elevate his offense to remain valuable to Toronto.

2. New York Yankees: Ryan McMahon

Original Contract: Six years, $70 millionRemaining Money: $32 million through 2027Ryan McMahon, acquired by the Yankees last season, struggled offensively, managing only a .208 batting average and .641 OPS. While his defensive skills are evident, particularly at third base with 10 defensive runs saved, his inability to perform against left-handed pitchers limits his value. McMahon has become a platoon player, leaving the Yankees in a difficult spot concerning his contract.

3. Boston Red Sox: Masataka Yoshida

Original Contract: Five years, $90 millionRemaining Money: $37.2 million through 2027Masataka Yoshida's time in the MLB has been underwhelming, especially considering his struggles in the outfield and lack of offensive contribution, with a mere 1.5 WAR over three seasons. His defensive issues have led the Red Sox to utilize him mainly as a designated hitter, and with a crowded outfield, his future in Boston seems uncertain.

4. Tampa Bay Rays: Gavin Lux

Original Contract: One year, $5.525 millionRemaining Money: $5.525 million through 2026Gavin Lux's performance has left much to be desired. Despite being a two-time World Series Champion, his lackluster .713 OPS and poor defensive runs saved make him an expensive addition to a team that doesn’t heavily invest in contracts. Although a one-year deal, his failure to establish himself as a reliable player is concerning.

5. Baltimore Orioles: Tyler O’Neill

Original Contract: Three years, $49.5 millionRemaining Money: $33 million through 2027O'Neill had bright moments, including a homer on Opening Day, but injuries have plagued his career. With only 53 games played last season and a low batting average of .199, his effectiveness remains in question. The Orioles seem poised to improve, leaving O'Neill fighting for a bench role.

The Importance of Redemption

The examples of deGrom and Springer show that it’s possible for players to bounce back and prove their worth to their respective teams after a tough period. However, for the players sitting on the brink of disappointment in 2026, the pressure is on to perform at a level that justifies their contracts. It speaks to the fluid nature of sports contracts; a player's performance can greatly impact their team’s success, and management must make tough decisions based on both player potential and financial implications.

Conclusion

As teams gear up for the 2026 season, several players are looking to turn the tide on their careers, just as Jacob deGrom and George Springer have done. Each one of these players has a story and the potential for a major turnaround. It will be crucial for them to focus on their strengths and rectify their shortcomings, paving the way for successful seasons that align with their hefty contracts. The landscape of baseball is ever-changing, and one year can make all the difference. With determination and hard work, many of these players could write a new narrative for their careers.