Introduction

The 2018 NFL Draft is often remembered as one of the most exciting quarterback classes in recent history. With five signal-callers selected in the first round, including four within the top 10 picks, expectations were sky-high. Fast forward to today, and this class has delivered remarkable performances, with four Pro Bowl selections and two MVP winners. However, it was Sam Darnold, now with the Seattle Seahawks, who capped off his journey by winning a Super Bowl. Let’s take a closer look at the 2018 quarterback class, revisiting the paths of these players and ranking them based on their NFL careers so far.

The 2018 Quarterback Class Overview

Thirteen quarterbacks were drafted in 2018, starting with Baker Mayfield, who became the first overall pick by the Cleveland Browns. Meanwhile, the Cincinnati Bengals selected Logan Woodside as the last quarterback at pick 249. Over the years, several quarterbacks from this class have established themselves in the league, with Darnold’s recent Super Bowl victory serving as a significant highlight amidst a tapestry of successes and struggles.

Ranking the Quarterbacks

As we reflect on the journey of these quarterbacks, here’s a re-ranking based on their contributions and current standings in the league.

1. Josh Allen (Buffalo Bills)

Originally drafted seventh overall, Josh Allen has proven to be a top-tier quarterback. His impressive stats include over 30,000 passing yards and 220 touchdown passes against just 98 interceptions over eight seasons. Allen has maintained a win-loss record of 88-39, showcasing his leadership. Despite the Bills' struggles in the playoffs, Allen remains a formidable dual-threat quarterback, rushing for significant yardage and being a constant goal-line threat. General managers would likely choose him to build their franchise around, given his elite performance and potential.

2. Lamar Jackson (Baltimore Ravens)

Lamar Jackson, drafted as the last pick of the first round, has demonstrated that he’s not just a productive starting quarterback but one of the league's most electrifying players. Twice named NFL MVP, he holds the record for the most rushing yards by a quarterback in a single season. However, his recent injury history raises concerns about his availability and performance consistency. His unique skill set remains valuable, but the Ravens must navigate contract challenges as they look to secure his future.

3. Sam Darnold (Seattle Seahawks)

Sam Darnold’s story is one of redemption. Once considered a 'bust', he turned his career around with a Super Bowl victory after a successful stint in Seattle. Darnold’s ability to win games—28 in the last two seasons—proves he can perform at a high level after years of uncertainty. His statistics reflect his growth, yet concerns over his turnover issues remain. Nonetheless, his Lombardi Trophy represents a significant turnaround for his image and career prospects.

4. Baker Mayfield (Tampa Bay Buccaneers)

Baker Mayfield, the first overall pick, has had a rollercoaster career with moments of brilliance and frustration. He has shown flashes of greatness, including a Pro Bowl season and leading the Browns to their first playoff victory in decades. However, he also faces scrutiny for inconsistency, particularly highlighted by leading the league in interceptions during 2024. As he enters the final year of his contract with Tampa, the pressure is on him to prove his worth and a long-term solution for the Buccaneers.

5. Mason Rudolph (Pittsburgh Steelers)

Mason Rudolph represents a more stable option in this quarterback class. Although he hasn’t shined like his peers, he has managed to secure a solid backup role, displaying commendable performances during his career. His statistics, including a .500 record in 19 starts, indicate he can hold his own during critical moments. He may not be a long-term starter, but he is valued for his reliability and experience.

6. Mike White (New York Jets / Carolina Panthers)

Finally, Mike White, while considered a journeyman quarterback, has made the most of limited opportunities. His brief stints as a starter, combined with moments of success, allow him a place in this ranking. He has shown some potential, with notable performances for the New York Jets, yet he may find himself as a backup in the future. His journey illustrates the ups and downs many players face as they seek to solidify their place in the NFL.

Conclusion

The 2018 quarterback class has brought a mix of triumphs and challenges across the NFL landscape. With Sam Darnold’s Super Bowl win as a noteworthy conclusion to this chapter, it’s evident that talent can shine through adversity. As we reflect on their journeys—from the highs of Pro Bowl selections to the lows of injury and inconsistency—we see how these quarterbacks have each carved their own path in the league. Their stories continue to unfold, making this class one of the most compelling narratives in recent NFL history.