Overview of MLB's Third Base Landscape for 2025

The landscape at third base in Major League Baseball is filled with a mix of established stars and emerging talents as we head into the 2025 season. Renowned players like José Ramírez, Manny Machado, Alex Bregman, and Matt Chapman have dominated the position for years. However, a new generation of talent, including Junior Caminero, Jordan Westburg, and Brett Baty, is making waves. This article ranks every MLB team's third baseman based solely on their offensive and defensive contributions this year.

Third Base Rankings and Player Evaluations

Our rankings evaluate players solely on their performance this season, reflecting neither past accomplishments nor future projections. Here’s a glimpse of the rankings from the least to the most distinguished third basemen heading into the 2025 season:

30. Cam Devanney, Pittsburgh Pirates

Offense: .167/.211/.222, 1 XBH (0 HR)Defense: 0 DRSAIR: -0.2

Devanney, the 28-year-old rookie, has stepped into the lineup following the departure of former Pirates stars, having previously excelled in Triple-A.

29. Brady House, Washington Nationals

Offense: .239/.251/.329, 3 HRDefense: -1 DRSAIR: -0.2

Once a highly-touted prospect, House has struggled in the Big Leagues but aims to solidify his spot heading into 2026.

28. Kyle Karros, Colorado Rockies

Offense: .242/.314/.319, 1 HRDefense: 2 DRSAIR: 0.2

The son of MLB star Eric Karros, Kyle has stepped up as the Rockies' primary third baseman after his debut.

27. Connor Norby, Miami Marlins

Offense: .247/.298/.373, 6 HRDefense: -9 DRSAIR: 0.1

Norby has the potential to be a long-term piece, despite recent injury setbacks.

26. Darell Hernaiz, Athletics

Offense: .250/.324/.358, 2 HRDefense: -3 DRSAIR: 0.4

Hernaiz offers hope amid a shaky third base situation for the Athletics this season.

25. Curtis Mead, Chicago White Sox

Offense: .248/.321/.338, 3 HRDefense: 0 DRSAIR: 0.4

After joining in a trade, Mead has begun to prove himself, showcasing solid minor league numbers.

24. Nolan Arenado, St. Louis Cardinals

Offense: .235/.294/.366, 10 HRDefense: 4 DRSAIR: 0.7

After a series of injuries, Arenado's performance has dipped, but he remains a staple in the lineup.

23. Alec Bohm, Philadelphia Phillies

Offense: .272/.319/.384, 9 HRDefense: -4 DRSAIR: 1.1

Despite a fall in performance, Bohm’s offensive capabilities still attract attention.

22. Royce Lewis, Minnesota Twins

Offense: .237/.293/.406, 12 HRDefense: 0 DRSAIR: 1.1

Injuries have hindered Lewis, but he has shown flashes of brilliance.

21. Blaze Alexander, Arizona Diamondbacks

Offense: .234/.328/.423, 7 HRDefense: 4 DRSAIR: 1.2

With increased playing time, Alexander is carving out a niche for himself.

20. Yoán Moncada, Los Angeles Angels

Offense: .239/.337/.459, 11 HRDefense: -9 DRSAIR: 1.0

When healthy, Moncada's offense shines, though defensive issues persist.

19. Josh Jung, Texas Rangers

Offense: .255/.297/.397, 13 HRDefense: -2 DRSAIR: 1.6

Jung’s ability to perform when it counts has kept him relevant this season.

18. Austin Riley, Atlanta Braves

Offense: .260/.309/.428, 16 HRDefense: -2 DRSAIR: 1.6

Injuries plagued Riley's season, but he remains reliable offensively.

17. Carlos Correa, Houston Astros

Offense: .274/.326/.394, 11 HRDefense: 0 DRSAIR: 1.9

Correa’s reacquisition has added depth to the Astros' infield.

16. Jordan Westburg, Baltimore Orioles

Offense: .276/.326/.473, 15 HRDefense: -5 DRSAIR: 1.9

Westburg’s all-star selection showcases his impact during a tumultuous season.

15. Ke'Bryan Hayes, Cincinnati Reds

Offense: .246/.297/.323, 5 HRDefense: 17 DRSAIR: 1.6

Hayes showcases elite defensive skills and has revitalized his performance in Cincinnati.

14. Matt Shaw, Chicago Cubs

Offense: .226/.294/.391, 11 HRDefense: 11 DRSAIR: 1.2

Shaw's late-season surge has solidified his future in Chicago.

13. Brett Baty, New York Mets

Offense: .254/.315/.434, 16 HRDefense: 2 DRSAIR: 2.0

Baty's versatility across the infield has made him a valuable asset.

12. Caleb Durbin, Milwaukee Brewers

Offense: .253/.326/.387, 10 HRDefense: 7 DRSAIR: 2.1

Durbin's emergence has provided stability to the Brewers' third base position.

11. Ryan McMahon, New York Yankees

Offense: .220/.319/.394, 19 HRDefense: 9 DRSAIR: 2.0

McMahon's recent trade solidifies the Yankees' infield roster.

10. Ernie Clement, Toronto Blue Jays

Offense: .275/.311/.398, 9 HRDefense: 11 DRSAIR: 2.6

Clement ranks as a reliable two-way player across the infield.

9. Zach McKinstry, Detroit Tigers

Offense: .266/.342/.447, 11 HRDefense: -7 DRSAIR: 3.2

A super-utility player, McKinstry's performance has been key for the Tigers this season.

8. Max Muncy, Los Angeles Dodgers

Offense: .255/.387/.486, 17 HRDefense: 1 DRSAIR: 2.7

Muncy continues to display power and discipline at the plate.

7. Alex Bregman, Boston Red Sox

Offense: .279/.361/.476, 16 HRDefense: 3 DRSAIR: 3.1

Bregman's healthy return has made an impact on the Red Sox lineup.

6. Junior Caminero, Tampa Bay Rays

Offense: .261/.301/.535, 41 HRDefense: -2 DRSAIR: 4.0

Caminero's talent with the bat remains evident, showing potential for stardom.

5. Eugenio Suárez, Mariners

Offense: .236/.307/.547, 45 HRDefense: -7 DRSAIR: 3.6

Suárez's offensive prowess keeps him among the top-tier third basemen.

4. Manny Machado, San Diego Padres

Offense: .278/.339/.462, 23 HRDefense: 1 DRSAIR: 3.5

Machado has remained consistent, continuing his Hall of Fame path.

3. Matt Chapman, San Francisco Giants

Offense: .241/.351/.457, 21 HRDefense: 5 DRSAIR: 3.9

Chapman's remarkable defensive skills make him a crucial part of the Giants’ plans.

2. Maikel García, Kansas City Royals

Offense: .283/.357/.501, 27 HRDefense: 1 DRSAIR: 5.3

García’s astounding improvement showcases his potential for greatness.

1. José Ramírez, Cleveland Guardians

Offense: .283/.360/.456, 30 HRDefense: 1 DRSAIR: 5.0

Ramírez continues to dominate, proving why he remains the top third baseman in the league.