Introduction

The 2024 NFL Draft will be remembered as a pivotal moment in football history, especially for its quarterback class. Six quarterbacks were selected on Day 1, with each one making a significant impact early in their careers. With four of these draftees winning playoff games and one reaching the Super Bowl, it’s the perfect time to re-evaluate their progress and potential. This article examines how these quarterbacks rank based on their successes in both the regular season and playoffs, along with their future prospects.

The Heavyweights: Jayden Daniels and Drake Maye

At the top of the list, Jayden Daniels shows great promise as the No. 2 overall pick in 2024. His ability to lead the Washington Commanders transformed a once-rebuilding franchise into a playoff contender. During his rookie season, Daniels notched an impressive 12 wins, completing 69% of his passes for 3,568 yards and 25 touchdowns. His dual-threat capability also allowed him to contribute significantly on the ground with 891 rushing yards and six rushing touchdowns.

However, 2025 presented challenges for Daniels, who struggled with injuries, forcing him to miss ten games. If he can return to his rookie form and maintain his health, Daniels is poised to be a top-tier quarterback in the NFL.

Drake Maye, the No. 3 pick, has emerged as a serious contender in the quarterback ranks. Initially starting behind Jacoby Brissett, Maye quickly found his footing, leading the New England Patriots not only to the playoffs but all the way to the Super Bowl. In 2025, he showcased his elite skills by throwing for 4,394 yards and 31 touchdowns, while achieving a 72% completion rate. His performance has solidified his status as a potential MVP and if he can clinch the Lombardi Trophy, Maye will establish himself as one of the league's top quarterbacks.

Middle of the Pack: Bo Nix and Michael Penix Jr.

Bo Nix, selected for the Denver Broncos, has built a solid reputation since entering the league. With a record of 24-10 and back-to-back playoff appearances, his leadership has contributed to the Broncos being perennial contenders. Nix, despite not having jaw-dropping statistics, has successfully managed games by averaging a completion rate of 64.8% and throwing for 3,853 yards and 27 touchdowns. His consistent availability has elevated his standing, even though concerns remain about his upside moving forward.

On the other hand, Michael Penix Jr., drafted by the Atlanta Falcons, has faced tumultuous times. Chosen eighth overall just after the Falcons signed veteran Kirk Cousins, Penix had an underwhelming rookie season followed by a string of injuries. Despite playing nine games, the team only secured three victories and Penix’s season ended abruptly due to a torn ACL. The pressure is now on him to convince the new coaching staff under Kevin Stefanski that he can be the reliable starter the Falcons have aspired to find.

The Risky Picks: J.J. McCarthy

Drafted at No. 10 overall by the Minnesota Vikings, J.J. McCarthy has yet to deliver on expectations. Although he displayed promise during his college days, he missed his entire rookie season due to a torn meniscus, which set back his development significantly. McCarthy's sophomore year did not see substantial improvement, as he finished with just 1,632 passing yards, 11 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions. Moreover, thoughts among teammates showcase concerns over his production, with All-Pro wideout Justin Jefferson expressing doubts about the team's overall effectiveness under McCarthy.

McCarthy’s potential may still linger, but he must focus on improving his health and performance in 2026 to avoid becoming a draft bust.

Shining Amidst the Struggles: Caleb Williams

While Caleb Williams, selected first overall by the Chicago Bears, faced significant trials, particularly in his rookie season, he has shown admirable resilience. Williams played behind an inadequate offensive line and was sacked a league-high 68 times, all while managing to throw for 3,541 yards and 20 touchdowns. In his second season, the Bears revamped their offense and paired Williams with a new coaching staff that included dynamic talent.

The changes proved effective, allowing Williams to contribute significantly to the Bears’ 12-win season and playoff berth. Although there’s room for growth in his game, it’s clear that Williams has the potential to become a franchise cornerstone as demonstrated by his ability to deliver crucial plays during tight matchups.

Conclusion

The 2024 NFL Draft quarterback class has already begun to show its promise and complexities, from dazzling performances to disappointing setbacks. As the league moves into the 2026 season and beyond, attention will be placed on how each quarterback responds to the challenges ahead. Will Williams overcome early struggles? Can McCarthy find his footing? These unfolding narratives will define not only their careers but also shape the future of their respective franchises.