As Super Bowl LIX approached, discussions surrounding Patrick Mahomes' legacy intensified. At the age of 29, Mahomes was poised to play in his fifth Super Bowl within six years. A victory would have made him the first quarterback in NFL history to win three consecutive Super Bowls and would have earned him four championship rings before reaching his 30th birthday. Some analysts suggested that such an achievement could position Mahomes as the greatest quarterback of all time, potentially surpassing the iconic Tom Brady.

However, the game unfolded in an unexpected manner, with the Philadelphia Eagles dominating the Kansas City Chiefs by a significant margin, ultimately winning 40-22. This marked the second time Mahomes faced a blowout loss in his Super Bowl career. While Mahomes' status as an elite quarterback remains unquestionable—evident in the Chiefs' unwavering confidence in him—his performance in Super Bowls has raised questions, especially after such a decisive defeat.

In the pre-game discussion, Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce expressed his belief to Rob Gronkowski of Fox Sports that Mahomes is already the greatest quarterback. Kelce acknowledged the validity of arguments in favor of other quarterbacks, especially given Brady's extensive Super Bowl success. Despite Mahomes' statistics in Super Bowl LIX—32 attempts, 21 completions, 257 yards, three touchdowns, and two interceptions—his performance during critical moments left much to be desired. Both of his interceptions significantly impacted the game's outcome: one was returned for a touchdown, while the other was thrown deep in Chiefs' territory. Additionally, a lost fumble led to an Eagles' field goal, emphasizing the defensive dominance exhibited by Philadelphia that day. Analysts, including Jeff Howe of The Athletic, pointed out that when evaluating quarterback greatness through Super Bowl success, the comparison between Mahomes and Brady remains stark, as Brady boasts a 7-3 record in Super Bowls, exhibiting unparalleled performance under pressure.