A key element that distinguishes a good team from a great one, or provides hope for fans of a struggling franchise, lies in players who surpass preseason expectations. An analysis of the most underrecognized talents for each MLB team in 2025 highlights promising young players, as well as veterans who are defying the odds early in the season. This examination caters to a national audience, offering insights to fans eager to understand the less celebrated figures contributing to their teams' successes.

For the New York Yankees, Fernando Cruz stands out as a noteworthy figure. Despite dealing with right shoulder inflammation, Cruz has posted a commendable 2.66 ERA in 21 games before his injury. Acquired in a trade that sent Jose Trevino to the Cincinnati Reds during the offseason, Cruz boasts an impressive strikeout rate of 13.3 K/9 across 23.2 innings during his inaugural season with the Yankees.

José Caballero of the Tampa Bay Rays made headlines last year by stealing an American League-best 44 bases. Nevertheless, he also faced challenges, being thrown out a league-worst 16 times. This season, Caballero has improved his success rate, converting 19 of 23 attempts. Additionally, he has significantly raised his OPS from .630 to .735, demonstrating his offensive growth.