NHL Playoff Predictions: Key Roster Decisions Ahead of Offseason

The 2025-26 NHL regular season is drawing to a close, with the final games set for Thursday and the excitement of the 2026 Stanley Cup playoffs kicking off this Saturday. As teams prepare for the postseason, speculation is growing around those who failed to qualify and their potential offseason roster moves.
Management Changes Stir Speculation
The New Jersey Devils and Toronto Maple Leafs are among the teams already seeking new leadership. With the Devils having recently parted ways with general manager Tom Fitzgerald, the incoming GM will be tasked with crucial decisions, including the future of star players like Nico Hischier, who is entering the final year of his contract. Hischier, a top-two-way center, is looking for a substantial extension, and his commitment to the team remains uncertain.
Meanwhile, over in Toronto, the Maple Leafs are navigating a tumultuous offseason after failing to qualify for the playoffs for the first time in nine years. General manager Brad Treliving was fired on March 31, and speculation is rife about possible trades and buyouts, including for players like defenseman Morgan Rielly, signed through 2029-30 but now under scrutiny.
Player Movements and Trade Rumors
For teams like the Seattle Kraken, significant decisions loom regarding pending free agents. Bobby McMann, who was acquired before the trade deadline, has made an immediate impact, scoring 9 goals and 13 points in just 15 games. McMann, finishing a two-year contract with an average annual value of $1.4 million, has shown potential for a long-term deal worth over $5 million. Talks for an extension between McMann and Kraken management are reportedly underway.
In contrast to McMann's rising stock, Canadiens goaltender Samuel Montembeault's status looks unstable. After an injury during last year's playoffs, Montembeault's performance has suffered, leaving him behind rookies Jakub Dobes and Jacob Fowler in the Canadiens' goalie lineup. With a year remaining on his contract at a manageable $3.15 million, speculation is mounting about whether he will be traded or bought out.
The Maple Leafs' Core Dynamics
The Maple Leafs' management search will likely focus on retaining core players like Rielly and team captain Auston Matthews. Rielly has expressed interest in remaining with the team but acknowledges changes might be coming and could be under review by the new GM. With just two years left on Matthews’s contract, ensuring his satisfaction with the team's direction becomes imperative. After a season-ending injury, Matthews's future is tied to the management's plans for the team.
Potential trade discussions surrounding Matthews have also sparked interest. The Pittsburgh Penguins could be looking for a star replacement for aging captain Sidney Crosby, and Matthews's relationship with GM Kyle Dubas from his time with the Leafs could open the door for a significant move. However, considering Matthews’s stature, he’s likely to remain with Toronto for the upcoming season.
Future Prodigy Discussions
Nico Hischier represents another pivotal decision for the Devils. His uncertain stance on a contract extension raises questions. Should he refuse to commit, trade scenarios are being discussed, including a deal with the Minnesota Wild or Ottawa Senators that would reunite him with family members or former teammates. However, there hasn't been significant movement or inclination from Hischier to leave New Jersey yet.
Impact of Coaching Changes
Coaching changes could play an essential role in the upcoming roster decisions. In Toronto, head coach Craig Berube could also face termination after a disappointing season. How this impacts the players and their willingness to adapt will shape the team’s strategy going forward. The broader implications of these management and coaching shakeups not only affect the current roster but could also influence potential signings and trades.
Conclusion: Looking Ahead
As teams enter the playoffs this weekend, the off-ice discussions regarding trades, contracts, and management decisions are heating up. The upcoming weeks will be critical for teams looking to reshape their rosters for the better, and with the salary cap positioning, multiple franchises, including the Devils, Maple Leafs, and Kraken, have significant decisions to make. Each choice during this period can have vast implications for the franchises’ futures.
