The New York Giants are confronting significant challenges following a disappointing 3-14 record in the 2024 season, marking the seventh occasion in the last eight years that the team has failed to make the playoffs. Frustration among fans is palpable, reflecting a broader concern about the direction of the organization.

An insider with knowledge of the Giants' operations described the team's decision-making process as being heavily influenced by external commentary, stating that it appears the key decision-makers are reacting to online conversations rather than strategic insights. This sentiment resonated particularly highlighted during a viral moment from the team’s appearance on Hard Knocks, which showcased discussions between ownership and management regarding running back Saquon Barkley’s impending free agency.

During the recent season, the Giants faced criticism for frequently altering their starting lineup, a move perceived by some as making changes for change's sake. Notably, quarterbacks Tommy DeVito and Drew Lock were swapped multiple times, reflecting a lack of consistency under center. Moreover, concerns have been raised about player communication, with several expressing feelings of being left uninformed about their roles and playing time. As the team looks ahead, owner John Mara is reportedly set to place a playoff mandate on general manager Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll for the 2025 season, implying that both will face intense scrutiny to significantly improve the team's performance.