As the 2025-26 NBA season approaches, players have made their assessments clear regarding who they believe stands out on both ends of the valuation scale—overrated and underrated. An anonymous survey conducted by The Athletic has shed light on these sentiments, providing a fascinating glimpse into player perceptions around the league.
Jalen Johnson and Derrick White Claim Underrated Honors
In an eye-opening revelation, Atlanta Hawks forward Jalen Johnson and Boston Celtics guard Derrick White have tied as the most underrated players in the league, according to their peers. This acknowledgment highlights Johnson's rapid rise following his team's recent roster changes, particularly after guard Trae Young was traded to the Washington Wizards in December.
Johnson had an impressive season that positioned him for All-NBA consideration. He delivered career highs in multiple categories, averaging 22.5 points, 10.3 rebounds, and 7.9 assists per game. His emergence as a cornerstone player for the Hawks has been notable, and this recognition from fellow players may serve as a catalyst for him to further elevate his game in the upcoming season.
Meanwhile, Derrick White’s recognition as underrated comes despite facing challenges. The 31-year-old averaged a respectable 16.5 points during the regular season but experienced the worst shooting season of his career, posting only 39.4 percent from the field and 32.7 percent beyond the arc. However, his contribution on the defensive end was undeniable; he finished sixth in Defensive Player of the Year voting, distinguishing himself as the top guard in the category. Solid defensive performances, even amid offensive struggles, solidify White's place in the players’ minds as someone who deserves more recognition.
A Closer Look at the Underrated Players
The survey not only highlighted Johnson and White but also identified several other players who are perceived as underrated. Following the duo, a four-way tie for third place emerged, featuring NBA stars Jaylen Brown, Jrue Holiday, Payton Pritchard, and Austin Reaves, each garnering support from 3.3% of the 151 votes cast.
Interestingly, three of the five players in the underrated category have ties to the Boston Celtics, emphasizing the team's depth and talent. Brown, Holiday, and Pritchard’s placements speak volumes about their capabilities and the recognition they seek in a league where accolades can sometimes overlook deserving talent.
Alperen Şengün at the Top of the Overrated List
On the flip side of the coin, Houston Rockets forward Alperen Şengün has earned the dubious distinction of being recognized as the league's most overrated player. This marks a significant shift for Şengün, who had not received any votes in the previous year’s survey. After securing a spot on the All-Star team for the past two seasons, his reputation has shifted, partly due to the Rockets' early playoff exits.
Voters expressed frustrations regarding Şengün's on-court performances, with one anonymous player stating, “He’s talented, but, dude, just play hard.” This sentiment illustrates that while many recognize his skills, there’s an expectation for him to elevate his intensity and consistency during games.
Rudy Gobert and Trae Young found themselves tied for second place in the overrated category, continuing their trend from the previous season where they also ranked high on the list. Gobert and Young have consistently faced scrutiny regarding their contributions and impact relative to the expectations surrounding them. Both players have large followings, and as such, their performances are scrutinized closely, leading to reiterations of their positions in these surveys.
Expectations Ahead of the New Season
The 2025-26 NBA season is shaping up to be pivotal for several players highlighted in the survey. For Johnson and White, there’s an opportunity to build on their recognition and elevate their games further. Johnson's role as the key player for the Hawks necessitates consistency, while White must convert his defensive accolades into more balanced offensive performances.
On the other hand, as the most overrated player, Şengün faces pressure to rectify perceptions. Houston's performance in the new season will heavily rely on his development and adjustment, particularly amid speculation regarding franchise dynamics and potential distractions. The arrival of new faces and potential changes in the roster will also play a significant role in whether the Rockets can turn their fortunes around.
As the league looks ahead, the opinions expressed by players through The Athletic's survey will undoubtedly stir discussions and motivate individuals to prove their critics wrong. Whether players can shake off their perceived undervaluation or step away from the overrated spotlight will define not just their careers, but also the dynamics of the teams they represent.
