Examining the Pressure on NHL Teams: A Look at the 2023-24 Season

Pressure within the NHL varies significantly from team to team, with some organizations aiming for improvement and a shot at the playoffs while others carry the hefty expectation of winning the Stanley Cup. As the clock counts down, the intensity of this pressure can fluctuate. For instance, the Florida Panthers have showcased their prowess by reaching the Stanley Cup Final in recent seasons, making the journey appear deceptively simple, especially following their success in the previous year. However, the pathway to the championship remains fraught with challenges, particularly for teams that have repeatedly fallen short of their ultimate goal. These organizations face increasingly difficult conversations at the end of each season, especially if they fail to achieve their objectives once more, prompting potential reevaluations of their strategies.
One team that exemplifies this situation is the Toronto Maple Leafs. Despite the team's previous efforts in the postseason, another negative outcome could lead to serious introspection regarding its long-term vision. The departure of Mitch Marner this summer after he opted not to re-sign with the team was a significant blow, as he is regarded as one of the top players in the league. Yet, the Maple Leafs do retain talent in Auston Matthews and William Nylander, alongside the re-signing of John Tavares and the extension for Matthew Knies. Nevertheless, questions remain regarding their aging defense and whether Morgan Rielly can effectively lead. The team's goaltending, featuring Joseph Woll and Anthony Stolarz, will also be scrutinized for its ability to contribute to Toronto's success. General Manager Brad Treliving's aggressive moves this summer signal an intention to enhance the team's physicality, aiming to compete with formidable rivals such as Florida, Ottawa, and Montréal. However, a failure to progress may once again leave fans wondering if the course they are on is the correct one.
The New York Rangers have also hinted at a substantial shift following their last season's performance and subsequent changes. With owner James Dolan unlikely to remain patient through a subpar season, the Rangers are clearly set on winning, and they have taken steps in that direction. The trades of Chris Kreider and K'Andre Miller seemed like departures from their expectations, yet the team refocused resources by acquiring J.T. Miller the previous season and signing Vladislav Gavrikov. Under new head coach Mike Sullivan, who is recognized for his coaching acumen, the Rangers maintain a strong roster with stars like Mika Zibanejad, Artemi Panarin, and Adam Fox. Nevertheless, Panarin's impending free agency next summer adds another layer of urgency, meaning that another unsuccessful season could necessitate significant changes for the franchise.
The Los Angeles Kings find themselves in a similar situation as they navigate the competitive landscape, particularly with the recent dominance of the Edmonton Oilers in the playoffs. After another early exit in the postseason last year, the organization witnessed a leadership change with Rob Blake's departure and Ken Holland stepping into the General Manager role. Holland's strategy has involved enhancing the team's veteran presence by signing established players like Cody Ceci and Brian Dumoulin. Despite possessing a promising group of younger talents, the Kings have yet to transition fully from their older core, featuring players like Anze Kopitar and Drew Doughty. If the team’s veteran experience does not yield results, management may have to consider parting ways with some long-standing members for the sake of the franchise's future.
The Washington Capitals faced mixed perceptions regarding their approach to free agency last year. Some analysts viewed their decisions as a desperate effort to secure a playoff spot for superstar Alex Ovechkin, while others recognized it as a strategic move to capitalize on previous successes. The addition of Jakob Chychrun was beneficial in bolstering the defensive unit alongside John Carlson, and the team ultimately delivered a strong season, finishing as the top team in the Eastern Conference. With Ovechkin firmly planted in Washington, the team appears well-positioned for another postseason run under the guidance of coach Spencer Carbery. However, planning for life beyond Ovechkin is essential, as failing to progress towards another Cup victory could complicate future decision-making.
The Dallas Stars are expected to draw interest this season, especially in light of their recent internal changes. Following a disappointing finish in the Western Conference Final for the third consecutive year, the organization solicited the return of Glen Gulutzan, who previously coached the team. Given the expectations surrounding contending teams, whether a familiar voice can reinvigorate the Stars remains to be seen. Additionally, the contract situation of elite forward Jason Robertson looms large, as he will be a restricted free agent next summer and an unrestricted one in two years. With significant investment already allocated to key players, if the Stars do not make substantial headway in the postseason, they may confront difficult decisions regarding their roster composition.
The Edmonton Oilers have positioned themselves in a distinctly urgent situation, existing in a defined window where winning becomes paramount. After a heart-wrenching series defeat to the Panthers in the 2024 finals, there are concerns about the team's ability to close the gap between them and their ultimate goal. The loss to Florida revealed inherent weaknesses in their roster that may be challenging to confront when facing a determined opponent. While the Oilers continue to exhibit dominance in the Western Conference, they face rigorous competition from teams like the Kings and Stars. As the upcoming season unfolds, the potential implications of Connor McDavid's future in Edmonton take center stage. Should the team fall short of winning the Stanley Cup and McDavid chooses not to sign an extension, management may face pressure to reconfigure the roster, leading to decisions that could reshape the franchise.








