With nearly a year passed since some of the most impactful trades of the 2023-24 NBA season, a clearer assessment of the benefits and drawbacks of each transaction has emerged. This retrospective serves as a reminder of the immediate post-trade opinions, illustrating how some major deals have aged positively for all parties involved, while others have skewed decidedly one-sided. A few trades remain in a gray area, likely awaiting further judgment until the involved picks materialize later in this decade. Notable deals involving James Harden, Pascal Siakam, OG Anunoby, and others warrant examination as the season progresses.

The first trade of interest involved the Dallas Mavericks and Charlotte Hornets. The Mavericks received P.J. Washington, alongside two second-round picks, while the Hornets acquired Seth Curry, Grant Williams, and a protected first-round pick for 2027. In assessing this trade, the Mavericks stand out with an 'A' grade. Washington, though not the highest-profile name traded last season, played a vital role in the team's success, contributing significantly after his transition to Dallas. His performance helped propel the Mavericks to a 21-9 record following the trade deadline, showcasing his effectiveness as a versatile three-and-D player. Conversely, the Hornets received a 'B' grade, achieving a first-round pick for Washington, but taking on Williams' lengthy contract may prove challenging, particularly with his current injury issues.

Another significant transaction saw the Mavericks acquire Daniel Gafford from the Washington Wizards, while sending off a package that included a first-round pick. This deal garnered a 'B' grade for the Mavericks as Gafford provided valuable contributions on the court, although he played less than anticipated during the postseason. The Oklahoma City Thunder, on the receiving end of a swap arrangement, earned an 'A' for their strategic maneuvering, giving up a late first-round pick in exchange for potential future benefits. The Wizards, fluid in their rebuilding efforts, were also awarded an 'A-' for snagging a first-round selection for a player not crucial to their long-term plans.

Moving on to the transaction involving the New York Knicks, who acquired OG Anunoby, Precious Achiuwa, and Malachi Flynn from the Toronto Raptors, while relinquishing RJ Barrett, Immanuel Quickley, and a second-round pick. Anunoby was regarded as an invaluable asset, leading to a 'B+' grade for the Knicks as his role solidified their status among contenders. Toronto countered with a 'B' grade, successfully integrating Barrett into their roster, wherein he thrived upon his arrival already showcasing notable improvements. Quickley similarly prospered in his new role, cementing his value despite injuries hampering his contributions this season.

Lastly, the high-profile trade involving James Harden, who joined the Los Angeles Clippers alongside P.J. Tucker, while the Philadelphia 76ers received a combination of players and future draft picks in return. The Clippers' acquisition has been rated a 'D+' due to serious concerns regarding their long-term outlook post-trade. While Harden's skills could not be understated, the influx of aging star players raised issues about future roster flexibility. The 76ers, however, received an 'A', reflecting their adept negotiations that netted them valuable picks while freeing themselves of a player with diminishing returns on performance.