The NFL landscape is tumultuous, particularly at the quarterback position where the scarcity of high-caliber players creates uncertainty for many teams. As franchises grapple with potential quarterback changes, the upcoming 2026 season finds several starting QBs on shaky ground. Analysts like Brad Gagnon from Bleacher Report have highlighted eight signal-callers whose jobs could be at risk as they navigate a competitive environment.
Jacoby Brissett: A Placeholder for Arizona?
Jacoby Brissett's tenure with the Arizona Cardinals is under a cloud of uncertainty as he stands firm in contract negotiations. With discussions reportedly at an impasse, his position as the team’s starter is anything but secure. Brissett, 33, did manage to register a commendable 94.1 quarterback rating in 2025, even though he led the team to just one victory.
Given Arizona’s struggles and a possible pivot to rookie Carson Beck, the chances for Brissett to maintain his starting role dwindle. Moreover, Gardner Minshew lurks in the background, adding further competition to keep an eye on as the team looks ahead to the talent-rich 2027 draft.
Atlanta's Quarterback Conundrum
The quarterback battle in Atlanta presents a unique set of challenges. With Michael Penix Jr. healing from a torn ACL and Tua Tagovailoa plagued by a history of concussions, the Falcons face an uphill battle regardless of who emerges as the starter. An injury to either player can swiftly change the dynamics of the competition.
Tagovailoa has shown promise, putting forth big plays in camp, but his past injuries remain a lingering risk. If concerns about his health arise or if his performance falters, the Falcons might lean on either Penix or Trevor Siemian. The looming prospect of the 2027 quarterback class may also spur them to make a change sooner rather than later.
Deshaun Watson's Last Chance in Cleveland
After a high-profile trade and a lucrative contract, Deshaun Watson’s performance has left the Cleveland Browns searching for answers. With only 19 starts under his belt due to injuries and an underwhelming win-loss record of 9-10, Watson faces a pivotal season under head coach Todd Monken. The Browns are giving him one last chance to show he can be the quarterback they envisioned when they acquired him.
If Watson fails to recapture his Pro Bowl form, the Browns may be compelled to explore other options, evaluating quarterbacks like Shedeur Sanders while keeping an eye on promising prospects in the 2027 draft. The franchise's future trajectory could hinge on Watson's performance this season.
Daniel Jones: The Colts' Gamble
Daniel Jones, having recently signed a lucrative two-year extension with the Indianapolis Colts, enters the season with heightened expectations. His extension, while favorable, is somewhat misleading as it is effectively a one-year commitment. The Colts are banking on him returning to form following a torn Achilles injury, and his performance is critical not only for their playoff aspirations but also for the job security of GM Chris Ballard and head coach Shane Steichen.
If Jones struggles, it may force the Colts into significant roster decisions, possibly turning to rookie Anthony Richardson or Riley Leonard. The pressure to succeed is palpable, as another failure to reach the postseason could lead to a complete overhaul in Indianapolis.
Future Uncertainty for Los Angeles’ Mendoza and Cousins
There's considerable buzz around Fernando Mendoza, the Las Vegas Raiders’ newly acquired first-round talent, but the team isn’t rushing him into action. Kirk Cousins, a seasoned quarterback, is expected to lead while Mendoza develops on the bench. Should Cousins excel — following a solid record with Atlanta — Mendoza might not see the field this season at all.
However, if the Raiders fall out of playoff contention, a transition to Mendoza could happen sooner than expected. These decisions will significantly impact Las Vegas's long-term outlook as they assess the capabilities of their potential franchise quarterback.
Kyla Murray’s Reclamation Project in Minnesota
Once a dynamic dual-threat for the Arizona Cardinals, Kyler Murray now finds himself vying for the starting job with the Minnesota Vikings. With a strong endorsement from the coaching staff and a notable lead in the quarterback competition, Murray's past performance will largely dictate his future.
If Murray falters, the Vikings may turn to rookie J.J. McCarthy, looking to invest in their long-term future. Murray's ability to connect with star players like Justin Jefferson will be key but will require consistency he has yet to display at the professional level.
Miami’s Malik Willis: The Future or Placeholder?
Malik Willis heads into the season with the Miami Dolphins after a promising stint with the Green Bay Packers. He has signed a three-year deal worth $67.5 million, tying him to the team as they consider their long-term quarterback prospects. However, if Willis struggles, a pivot to rookie drafts in 2027 could be in store.
With an underwhelming support cast in Miami, Willis must capitalize on his opportunity to avoid comparisons with his time in Tennessee, where he faced adversity at nearly every turn.
Geno Smith: A Temporary Solution for the Jets
Acquired from the Raiders, Geno Smith's position with the New York Jets appears to be temporary at best. As the franchise positions itself for a strong showing in the 2027 draft, they aim to revitalize their offense with Smith. While he provides experience and stability for the Jets this season, he could easily be replaced by younger prospects such as Cade Klubnik if Smith falters.
As the NFL evolves, these quarterback situations underscore the unpredictable nature of the league. The coming season is sure to deliver drama, as teams restructure their rosters and strategize for not only immediate success but future franchise stability.
