The Edmonton Oilers have often been characterized by their impressive top-end talent, but a recurring narrative has suggested that the team lacks the depth necessary for championship success. This view posits that while the Oilers possess the offensive prowess to compete with any team, they have historically struggled defensively in the playoffs. Additionally, critiques have noted a lack of physicality, which may hinder their ability to flourish against more rugged opponents in lengthy series. However, this narrative is set to shift as the Oilers make their second consecutive appearance in the Stanley Cup Final following a dominant 6-3 victory over the Dallas Stars in Game 5 of the Western Conference Final. This time, the Oilers bring with them a deeper, more balanced roster and an advantageous home-ice position.

Critiques regarding the supporting cast surrounding superstars Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl have, at times, been justified. Recent history recalls the Edmonton teams of 2020 and 2021, where the impressive statistics of McDavid and Draisaitl were overshadowed by disappointing playoff exits. During those seasons, the reliance on less impactful players led to early-round exits against stronger teams such as the Chicago Blackhawks and Winnipeg Jets. The Oilers’ struggles were evident as they won only one of eight playoff games during those years. While McDavid and Draisaitl are widely acknowledged as one of the finest player duos in the sport, their quest for a championship was thwarted in subsequent seasons by successful opponents, notably the Colorado Avalanche and the Vegas Golden Knights, who showcased their depth and experience.

The Oilers' distancing from previous narratives began during the current 2024-25 season. After facing adversity early in the playoffs, including a challenging opening round against Los Angeles, Edmonton made strategic adjustments by switching goaltenders and tightening their systems. These transformations led to a notable turnaround, evidenced by their dominance in Games 3 through 6 of that series. Even when faced with difficulties, such as injuries and setbacks against Vegas, the team displayed resilience and determination, culminating in a series win highlighted by consecutive shutouts. As they entered the third round against Dallas, concerns resurfaced when a promising two-goal lead evaporated, which led to skepticism about their defensive capabilities. Yet, under coach Kris Knoblauch's guidance, an evolution has taken shape, marking a significant developmental stage for the Oilers. With the re-emergence of key players and contributions from unexpected sources, such as acquisitions Kasperi Kapanen and John Klingberg, the Oilers appear poised for success. McDavid has once again captivated fans and analysts alike with his skill and determination, while the support from the complementary players enhances the Oilers' chances in the Stanley Cup Final.