2025 NFL Draft Class: Quarterback Overview

The NFL draft class of 2025 attracted mixed opinions, especially regarding the quarterback position. Despite initial skepticism, the 13 quarterbacks selected during the event have seen varying degrees of success early in their careers. While some have established themselves as starters, others have struggled, finding themselves on practice squads or relegated to backup roles. As we transition to the 2026 NFL season, each quarterback faces a defining Year 2, with the potential to impress or falter. Let's delve into the trajectories of these young quarterbacks and offer realistic expectations for the upcoming season.

Jalen Milroe, Seattle Seahawks

Milroe was drafted by the Seahawks primarily as a backup plan should Sam Darnold not meet expectations. However, with Darnold leading Seattle to a Super Bowl victory, Milroe's role as a backup is more solidified heading into the 2026 season. In his rookie year, Milroe only saw three snaps on offense, following a fumble that kept him on the bench. The coaching staff may explore innovative ways to incorporate Milroe into the game plan, potentially as a third-string quarterback. Realistic Expectation: QB3 with occasional snaps in specific packages.

Dillon Gabriel, Cleveland Browns

Gabriel’s struggles were palpable during his six starts for the Browns in his rookie season, leading to a disappointing 1-5 record and lackluster statistics, with fewer than 60% of his passes completed. With Deshaun Watson returning and Shedeur Sanders taking the reins, Gabriel appears set to remain a third-string quarterback in 2026, as he aims to rehabilitate his image within the organization. Realistic Expectation: QB3, only moving to QB2 if Watson or Sanders misses time.

Will Howard, Pittsburgh Steelers

Howard's hopes of securing a starting position vanished with Aaron Rodgers' decision to return, placing him in a competitive situation behind a career veteran. He’ll have to vie against Mason Rudolph and rookie Drew Allar to establish his place. A trade of Rudolph could open doors for Howard, but until that time, he is likely to be the third option. Realistic Expectation: QB3 unless team splits with Rudolph.

Kyle McCord, Green Bay Packers

McCord spent his rookie season on the practice squad and was picked up by the Packers this offseason, facing a tough competition for the backup position against Tyrod Taylor and undrafted rookie Kyron Drones. Given Taylor's experience and Drones' versatility, McCord's chances of making the roster look slim. Realistic Expectation: Cut.

Graham Mertz, Houston Texans

Mertz’s chances at success remained bleak despite the Texans' struggles due to C.J. Stroud's inconsistency. As the third-string quarterback, Mertz is unlikely to see significant playing time in 2026 unless major changes occur within the roster, such as a trade of Davis Mills. Realistic Expectation: QB3, slotting up to QB2 if Mills gets traded.

Cam Miller, Miami Dolphins

Miller finds himself in a similar predicament to McCord as he joins the Dolphins after a lackluster stint with the Raiders. With competition from Malik Willis and Mark Gronowski, Miller's best chance will be to secure a practice squad spot, likely unable to make a significant impact in the coming season. Realistic Expectation: Practice squad member.

Kurtis Rourke, San Francisco 49ers

Rourke steps into a solid 49ers quarterback situation with Brock Purdy as the starter and Mac Jones as backup. Rourke’s goal will be to impress enough in training camp to potentially emerge as the second-string if the team decides to trade Jones. Realistic Expectation: QB3, slotting up to QB2 if Jones is dealt.

Shedeur Sanders, Cleveland Browns

Sanders had a respectable rookie season as the Browns’ starter but faces intense competition from Deshaun Watson. While he demonstrated potential during his starts, Watson's experience and contract commitment put Sanders' role in a precarious position as both quarterbacks vie for supremacy. Realistic Expectation: QB2 barring an injury or ineffective stretch from Watson.

Riley Leonard, Indianapolis Colts

Following injuries to key players, Leonard found himself thrust into a starting role late last season and showcased impressive skills, earning him the QB2 position for 2026. As long as he remains healthy, Leonard is in a prime position to back up Daniel Jones effectively. Realistic Expectation: Firm QB2 behind Jones.

Quinn Ewers, Miami Dolphins

Despite showing promise as a rookie, Ewers now has stiff competition from the newly signed Malik Willis, which jeopardizes his opportunity to play this season. Ewers must significantly improve during training camp if he wants to avoid being relegated to the bench again. Realistic Expectation: QB2 with high potential to get another chance to start.

Tyler Shough, New Orleans Saints

Shough's unexpected success after taking over for Derek Carr has the Saints believing they've secured their franchise quarterback. Now with new weapons around him, his performance will be pivotal for the team's offense. If all goes as planned, Shough is poised for significant growth in Year 2. Realistic Expectation: Top-16 QB.

Jaxson Dart, New York Giants

Dart enters a crucial season following a transformative offseason for the Giants. With heightened expectations from new acquisitions, Dart's ability to stay healthy and productive is critical as he looks to lead the Giants back to contention. Realistic Expectation: Top-10 QB, Pro Bowler.

Cam Ward, Tennessee Titans

As the No. 1 overall pick, Ward showed flashes of brilliance in a challenging season. With significant improvements to Tennessee's roster, including the addition of top-tier receivers, Ward is set to thrive in 2026. If he can capitalize on the team's efforts to bolster his supporting cast, he could emerge as a top franchise quarterback. Realistic Expectation: Top-12 QB.