The final day of the NFL draft has historically been a period filled with uncertainty as teams gamble on players who could become hidden gems. Year after year, some of these long-shot prospects defy expectations, stepping up as vital contributors much sooner than anticipated. Recent examples include San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy, who transformed from 'Mr. Irrelevant' into a Super Bowl starter, and Los Angeles Rams running back Kyren Williams, who turned a fifth-round selection into an impressive sixth in the NFL for rushing yards. Stars like these not only exceed the projected expectations; they emerge rapidly in the NFL landscape.

This year's draft showcased several players with the potential to make immediate impacts in the league as rookies. With an eye on 2026, let's dive into some of the standout selections from Day 3 that could reshape their teams' fortunes.

Jonah Coleman: A Versatile Threat for the Broncos

At Round 4, Pick No. 108, the Denver Broncos selected Jonah Coleman, a running back out of Washington who showcased his versatility and productivity in college, amassing over 1,000 rushing yards and 25 touchdowns in the last two seasons. Broncos head coach Sean Payton highlighted Coleman's unique ability to handle pass protection—an essential skill set for any running back transitioning to the NFL.

Last season, the Broncos struggled with their ground game, averaging just under 118 rushing yards per game. Yet, instead of making significant changes, they opted to re-sign veteran JK Dobbins, who has had his share of injuries. Coleman has a pathway to significant playing time, especially considering Dobbins' history of missed games. If Coleman can prove adept in pass protection, it's plausible he could emerge as a lead back for the team, joining the ranks of impactful performers from the draft.

Elijah Sarratt: Lighting Up the Ravens’ Offense

Another promising selection came in Round 4 with the Baltimore Ravens choosing wide receiver Elijah Sarratt at Pick No. 115. Sarratt was instrumental in Indiana's national championship success, leading the FBS with 15 touchdown receptions. Despite being overshadowed by teammate Omar Cooper Jr., who was drafted earlier, Sarratt's route-running skills and physical presence make him an attractive option for the Ravens.

With questions surrounding the depth of their receiving corps following the departure of Isaiah Likely, Sarratt could find himself in a favorable position. According to Bleacher Report's Moe Moton, he is expected to play a role in the slot, competing against solid options like Zay Flowers and Rashod Bateman. His ability to score touchdowns could make him a surprise asset in the Ravens' passing game as early as his rookie season.

Beau Stephens: Strengthening Seattle’s Offensive Line

Round 5 saw the Seattle Seahawks selecting guard Beau Stephens at Pick No. 148. The decision to secure Stephens surprised many, as the Seahawks came into the offseason with few glaring needs, yet their offensive line needed reinforcements. Standing 6'6” and weighing 315 pounds, Stephens excelled in zone-blocking schemes during his college career at Iowa, making him a fitting addition for Seattle's offensive system.

Michael Hanich from SI noted that Stephens possesses key attributes that can bolster the team's interior line. His smooth transition to the NFL could be critical, especially with the struggles observed in pass protection last season. Although it can be challenging to predict early success for Day 3 offensive linemen, Seattle's choice reflects their investment in developing Stephens into a potential starter.

Caden Curry: Edge-Rushing Potential for the Colts

In Round 6, at Pick No. 214, the Indianapolis Colts took edge-rusher Caden Curry from Ohio State, who made a significant impact during his lone starting year with 11 sacks. While Curry’s lack of exceptional arm length caused him to drop in the draft, Colts general manager Chris Ballard views him as a potential steal. His past role at Ohio State and strong recommendations from coaching staff suggest he could provide the team with much-needed edge production.

Defensive consistency has evaded the Colts in recent years, making Curry’s ability to carve out a rotational role crucial. If he impresses during training camp, he may find himself leading the edge rush rotation, solidifying the Colts' defensive unit.

Kyle Louis and Keionte Scott: Defensive Versatility for Miami and Tampa

Two additional noteworthy selections on Day 3 were Kyle Louis, a linebacker from Pitt, and Keionte Scott, a cornerback from Miami, both chosen in Round 4. Louis, who averaged over 90 tackles and intercepted six passes in his last two seasons, presents a versatile defensive option for the Miami Dolphins despite questions about his size. Miami's defensive coordinator Jeff Hafley expressed enthusiasm for finding ways to utilize Louis's skills in various roles.

Scott was selected by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, who were drawn to his aggressive playstyle and tackle production. Given the unsettled depth at the cornerback position, Scott has a chance to secure a meaningful role early on. His versatility allows for interesting defensive schemes that could benefit Tampa immensely.

The convergence of talent, situation, and a bit of luck define success in the NFL Draft. As we look towards the 2026 season, players like Coleman, Sarratt, Stephens, Curry, Louis, and Scott may just be the long-shot gems that make a significant difference for their teams.