The 2025 NBA All-Star starters have been officially announced, generating discussions regarding potential snubs. While it is easy to criticize the selection process by highlighting players who could have been included, it is crucial to acknowledge those who did earn a spot while also considering the merits of those left out. This analysis aims to provide a balanced perspective on the All-Star starter selections.

In the case of Darius Garland and Donovan Mitchell, determining who deserves the starting position is a complex decision. Jalen Brunson's performance, averaging more points and assists with superior efficiency compared to Mitchell, raises questions about which player should secure a slot. Mitchell's scoring numbers are slightly higher, averaging 23.2 points per game against Garland's 21.2, but Garland has demonstrated increased efficiency, particularly with self-created shots. However, both players face different defensive challenges. While Mitchell often encounters tougher defensive matchups, Garland contributes a larger share of the Cleveland Cavaliers' offensive output, particularly in terms of assists. Despite these differences, the evaluation becomes a matter of personal preference, as both players have compelling arguments for their inclusion in the All-Star ranks.

Regarding Victor Wembanyama, his exclusion from the starters' list is nothing short of a notable snub. The 21-year-old phenom is averaging 24.6 points and boasts an impressive 59.2 True Shooting Percentage, alongside 10.8 rebounds, 3.8 assists, 1.1 steals, and 4.0 blocks per game. The rationale for preferring Kevin Durant and LeBron James over Wemby does not hold when considering their respective team standings, especially since the Phoenix Suns hold only a slight advantage over the San Antonio Spurs in the win-loss column. Moreover, when evaluating net ratings, San Antonio performs better with Wembanyama on the court than the Suns or Lakers do with Durant and James, respectively. Wemby’s individual statistics further underscore his all-around talent, suggesting that his exclusion from the starting lineup is a missed acknowledgment of the new talent emerging in the league.

The selection of LeBron James over Anthony Davis as a starter aligns with the expectations of fan voting. James garnered nearly 1 million more fan votes than Davis, reflecting his legendary status and continued performance at a high level. However, many observers argue that Davis has been more valuable to the Los Angeles Lakers this season. While James manages a higher overall workload thanks to his playmaking ability, Davis has shown he can create his own shots, leading to more consistent offensive production. With Davis averaging 25.7 points per game compared to James' 23.7, it raises questions about meritocracy within the All-Star voting process. This analysis posits that based on the current season's performance alone, Anthony Davis deserves a place among the starting players.