Introduction

The 2024 NFL Draft class burst onto the scene with a promise of transformation, particularly notable with half of the first 12 selections being quarterbacks. As the season unfolded, the impact of this draft class began to be felt across the league, culminating in standout performances that have altered the trajectory of multiple franchises. With players like Bo Nix and Drake Maye heading to the AFC Championship Game, and others like Jayden Daniels leading their teams deep into the playoffs, the question arises: would teams make different choices if given a chance to re-draft? In this analysis, we venture into what a re-draft of the 2024 class would look like, focusing on the selections that could have changed the league's landscape even further.

Revisiting the Quarterback Choices

The Chicago Bears made headlines by selecting Caleb Williams, who initially sparked excitement but faced early challenges. Fast forward two years, and the second-year star finds himself amidst MVP conversations. However, Drake Maye of North Carolina has emerged as a massive contender for this re-draft. He recorded an impressive Total QBR of 77.2, leading his team with a consistency that gives him the edge over Williams. Given their respective performances, if teams could redo their picks, Maye would likely be the first quarterback chosen.

Commanders' Dilemma: Jayden Daniels vs. Caleb Williams

Jayden Daniels, drafted by the Commanders, has proven to be a dynamic dual-threat option. Despite struggling with injuries that limited him to just seven games in one season, his poise and leadership have driven his team to the NFC Championship Game. It's a difficult situation for the Commanders as they might have been tempted to draft Caleb Williams instead, who has shown flashes of brilliance when surrounded by the right support. Nonetheless, Daniels' playoff success keeps him in place as the number two pick in this hypothetical re-draft.

The Patriots Move to Secure a Star

In this scenario, the New England Patriots miss out on their franchise quarterback in Williams but could select a star talent instead, perhaps Marvin Harrison Jr. at wide receiver. Harrison’s production has been impressive, but selecting someone like Bo Nix could provide the Patriots the high-impact quarterback they seek. The opportunity to pair him with a strong coaching staff ensures the Patriots would become a playoff threat rather quickly.

Evaluating Defensive Stars and Offensive Needs

The 2024 draft showcased a myriad of defensive talents that could easily shift the fortunes of their respective teams. Jared Verse, who has already become a two-time Pro Bowler in his current role, could see himself selected as a top-five talent in a re-draft due to the undeniable value he brings on the edge. Additionally, you have prospects like Quinyon Mitchell and Cooper DeJean, who have excelled with All-Pro honors, making them essential picks for teams needing defensive reinforcements.

Reassessing Receiver Needs

The ever-evolving league landscape highlights the critical importance of receivers. While Malik Nabers dazzled with outstanding rookie statistics, his place could be contested, especially with talents like Brock Bowers and Ladd McConkey also pushing for a selection in the first round. The Giants could leverage Nabers’ explosive talent while the Ravens would benefit immensely from adding a player who can maintain possession and provide a deeper threat on offense.

Lamenting Missed Opportunities on Offensive Linemen

As teams recognize the fundamental role of a strong offensive line, it’s essential to consider those who didn’t meet expectations due to injuries or inconsistencies. Joe Alt’s prospects have dimmed due to injuries limiting his playtime. If teams could reassess, they might prioritize the likes of Olu Fashanu instead to protect their quarterbacks. This is especially true for teams like the Jets, desperately trying to find stability at QB.

Final Thoughts: The Impact of a Re-Draft

The exercise of reimagining the 2024 Draft is more than just an academic endeavor; it illustrates the ripple effects decisions make in the NFL. Each team's current composition, success, and potential future hinge on these crucial picks. As the league progresses, clubs will critically evaluate their past choices from this promising draft class, recognizing the potential shifts that a do-over could invoke. Whether the teams succeed in this guessing game will only unfold with time, and the possibilities remain tantalizing.